|31st December |
Ambassador to India decries Russian prosecution of holy book on charges of extremism
26th December 2011. From monstersandcritics.com
Russia has expressed regret over a Siberian court trial considering a ban on a one Hindu holy book causing an 'uproar' in India.
State prosecutors in Tomsk seek to ban the Russian translation of the Bhagavad Gita , contending it is an
extremist religious text that should be banned. They said the book spreads social discord, the IANS news agency reported.
Russian Ambassador to India Alexander Kadakin said:
I consider it categorically
inadmissible when any holy scripture is taken to the courts. For all believers these texts are sacred.
He claimed that Russia was a secular and democratic country where all religions enjoyed equal respect.
The Siberian court is
expected to deliver its verdict in the case on December 28.
Update: Not banned
31st December 2011. See
article from en.wikinews.org
judge in Tomsk, Russia drew a round of applause from the court room as she dismissed charges of extremism against the Bhagavad Gita As It Is , a Russian commented translation of the Bhagavad Gita published by the International Society for
Krishna Consciousness. This decision put an end to the six-month-long trial of the book accused by the state prosecutors of fostering social discord and incitement to religious hatred .
The Indian Foreign Ministry, which had been
urging Moscow to avert the possible ban they termed as absurd , welcomed the verdict calling it a sensible resolution of a sensitive issue which demonstrates yet again that the people of India and Russia have a deep understanding of each
other's cultures and will always reject any attempt to belittle our common civilizational values and thanked the Russian government for their support.
The controversial court case on the Bhagavad Gita, an ancient text regarded sacred by
millions of Hindus, had caused political and societal turmoil in India, with the Indian Parliament stalled over the proposed ban and Hindu activists burning Russian flags. The trial also evoked strong criticism from the international media.
|4th December ||
Spanish Customs ban rugby biography over the word 'needle' in the title
See article from
A book about legendary All Black coach Sir Fred Allen has been seized by Spanish customs apparently due to the dumb assumption that the word 'needle' in the title is related to illicit drugs.
Les Watkins, who co-wrote the biography Fred The
Needle , sent two copies of the book to Benidorm in Spain. He explained:
Apparently, the authorities there have clamped down on books believed to contain pornography or other undesirable material.
As far as we can work out, they pounced on the word 'needle' in the title, assuming it must be somehow linked to drugs being injected.
The books were first returned to New Zealand in early November with a bill for
On November 10 Watkins tried again, spending another $70 to resend the books. By November 28 the books still had not arrived, but NZ Post had picked up the story and tracked the books to the Spanish customs department, where
they had been impounded.
Pesumably hoping that press interest would make bring Spanish Customs to their senses, Watkins said: With any luck, he might get the books by Christmas.
|3rd December |
Nutter MP presents a petition backing her call to appoint the BBFC as book censors for sex education material
Conservative MP Andrea Leadsom has presented a 45,000 signature petition to Schools Minister Nick Gibb.
Leadsom is campaigning against explicit sex education in primary schools and feels that the BBFC are ideally placed to provide their censorship
expertise to sex education materials. She said:
The Department for Education is currently drafting new guidelines for schools on sex and relationship education (SRE) and I would like to see a form of independent
classification of the material used. The British Board of Film Classification (BBFC) has been rating films for 99 years and seems to be well placed to assess material, and I am sure that this would give worried parents some peace of mind in knowing what
their children were seeing.
To see some of the images being shown to very young children in our primary schools was genuinely shocking.
After presenting the petition, Leadsom had a meeting with Gibb and a
number of Northamptonshire parents. I know the Minister takes this matter very seriously and I hope he will take on board my idea of allowing the BBFC to age rate material , she said.
|26th November |
Libya celebrates the unbanning of books after the demise of Gadhafi
See article from
Libya marked the end of the Gadhafi-era blacklist with a ceremonial unbanning of books in the former regime's public library.
Many of Libya's emerging political hopefuls joined militia leaders and returning expat exiles at the Italianate Royal
Palace for a sunset event..
With a fanfare of Libyan bagpipers in full ceremonial flourish, the VIP crowd made its way to the top for of the palace, heaped with table upon table of books deemed unreadable during Moammar Gadhafi's 42-year rule.
There, Arabic titles including The Secret Life of Saddam Hussein and The CIA Files of Arab Rulers sat alongside censored troves of Islamic literature, theology and philosophy. Books about Israel, Hezbollah, books by Salmon Rushdie. One
slim volume was titled Sex In The Arab World.
Among the attendees was journalist and human rights activist Hassan al-Amin, one of the Gadhafi regime's sharpest critics during his years of exile in London, who shared a bittersweet swirl of
emotions as the books were revealed.
This is a major moment for us because this is where we reclaim our intellectual freedom. We say goodbye to an era where free thinking was forbidden, where ideas were dangerous, Amin told the Star.
|25th November |
New Zealand book police ludicrously seize Bloody Mama, an innocuous book banned 40 years ago
23rd November 2011. See
article from stuff.co.nz
An old book declared indecent and banned way back in 1971 has been seized from a Wellington bookstore by government officials.
Bloody Mama by Robert Thom has been listed for sale on Book Haven's website for $8.50 since February,
store owner Don Hollander said: It got seized today. A very nice chap from the DIA [Department of Internal Affairs] with a fancy badge came by.
The book is based on a true story about Kate Ma Barker who raised her sons to be
criminals in the 1930s. A film was also made about Ma Barker starring Shelley Winters and a young Robert de Niro.
I had a quick look through for the dirty bits or the nasty bits and it didn't see any, Hollander said.
The book was
deemed indecent and banned by the now defunct Indecent Publications Tribunal 40 years ago, however the ruling still stands. The tribunal was replaced by the Office of Film and Literature Classification in 1993.
25th November 2011. See article from
A New Zealand book censor has been given the task of reading a banned book seized this week, to see if it can be cleared for sale. The title, Bloody Mama ,
was seized by government officials from a Wellington book store.
The bo0ok was banned in 1971 by the now-defunct Indecent Publications Tribunal due to its indecency . Commentators have said that the book possibly suggests an incestuous
relationship between Barker and her sons.
The book would be read by a censor and a decision was likely in two months, adviser Michelle Baker said.
It has also been revealed that instead of cataloguing banned books in a forbidden library,
the classification office destroys them (presumably by the traditional means of burning).
|23rd November |
German church has decided to sell book publisher Weltbild after fracas about erotic novels
See article from
The Catholic church in Germany is to sell Weltbild, its bookselling arm, after the unit admitted last month to publishing erotic novels.
Weltbild is one of Germany's major book publishers. Catholic leaders were outraged that the profitable
company's book range included steamy pulp novels with titles like Boarding School for Sluts and The Lawyer's Whore and advice on how to practise esoteric superstitions.
Germany's 27 bishops met this week to press the 12 bishops who
co-owned Weltbild to end the investment after Weltbild defended its commercial policy of publishing whatever books met market demand.
Weltbild said it welcomed the decision to seek new ownership without delay .
|10th November |
No, but the nonsense of British libel law can
article from independent.co.uk
A man is set to appear in the High Court to defend himself against libel allegations over a book review he wrote on Amazon's website last year.
Vaughan Jones cannot afford representation and is having to defend himself alongside barristers
acting on behalf of internet giant Amazon and Richard Dawkins who are also named as co-defendants. The Richard Dawkins Foundation had also published an article by Jones on its website.
The case is being brought by Chris McGrath who wrote and
self-published a little known book entitled The Attempted Murder of God: Hidden Science You Really Need to Know .
Libel reform campaigners have expressed concern that the hearing is another example of how Britain's defamation laws
disproportionately favour claimants, closing down debate particularly among individuals and organisations who cannot afford costly legal battles.
John Kampfner, the Chief Executive of Index on Censorship, one of the founding partners of the Libel
Reform Campaign, said:
That a family man from Nuneaton can face a potentially ruinous libel action for a book review on Amazon shows how archaic and expensive our libel law is. We're pushing the government to commit to
a bill in the next Queen's speech so that these chilling laws are reformed to protect freedom of expression.
|10th November |
Azerbaijan to introduce extreme penalties for sidestepping the country's religious book censor
Based on article from
Prison terms of up to five years, or maximum fines of nearly nine years' worth of official minimum wage, are set to be adopted by Azerbaijan's parliament in mid-November. The extreme penalties will be applicable for groups of people who produce or
distribute religious literature without going through Azerbaijan's compulsory prior state censorship of all religious literature.
Also due are new punishments for those who lead Muslim worship if they have gained their religious education abroad,
Forum 18 News Service has learnt.
The punishments are included in proposed amendments to the Criminal and Administrative Codes approved by two parliamentary committees on 28 October.
|9th November |
Pope says prostitution, pornography threaten the human dignity of women (whereas a
religious ban on sex threatens the human dignity of children)
See article from
The pope has called for an end to prostitution and pornography, saying the practices denigrate women and represent a serious lack of humanity.
The pope made the remarks as he welcomed Reinhard Schweppe as Germany's ambassador to the Holy
See Nov. 7. The pope's talk focused on the church's role in defending human dignity... and no doubt the issue that the catholic church owned publisher, Weltbild, has been spotted publishing erotica.
The pope said:
A relationship that does not take into account the fact that a man and a woman have the same dignity represents a serious lack of humanity.
With the materialistic and hedonistic tendencies that seem to be
gaining space in the West, there is a growing form of discrimination against women.
The moment has come to energetically halt prostitution as well as the widespread distribution of material with an erotic and pornographic content,
including through the Internet in particular.
The pope said the Holy See would encourage and assist the Catholic Church in Germany so efforts against these types of abuse would be more decisive and clearer.
|7th November |
Malaysia's religious books censor bans reprehensibly titled sex guide
See article from
Malaysia's Home Ministry has banned the Obedient Wives Club's (OWC) controversial sex guide book with immediate effect. The book was written by Hatijan Aam, who is also the founder of the OWC.
Those found in possession of the reprehensibly titled,
Seks Islam, Perangi Yahudi Untuk Kembalikan Seks Islam Kepada Dunia ( Islamic Sex, Fighting Jews to Return Islamic Sex to the World ) could be fined up to RM5,000 (S$2,000). Those found reproducing the book for the purpose of offering it
for sale could be jailed up to three years or fined not exceeding RM20,000, or both.
The Home Ministry's religious book censor, grandiosely titled, Al-Quran Text and Publishing Control Division Secretary, Abdul Aziz Md Nor, said the book had been
banned to the public.
Aziz said the first reason was the book was released by an organisation that had clear links with the banned al-Arqam. As the movement has been banned, anything related to it, such as the club and the book, are also
banned. He said the contents of the book also violated Jakim's Islamic publication material censorship guideline. Based on our investigation and Jakim's findings, we must ban the book, he said.
See more about the book from
|4th November |
Publishers of TinTin in the Congo cover it with a protective band warning of historic racist content
See article from telegraph.co.uk
The Campaign for Real Education has condemned his publishers as over the top for deciding to package one of his early adventures, Tintin in the Congo , in shrink-wrap and with a warning about its content.
George Remi, the Belgian
artist better known as Herge, first published his tale of derring-do in Africa in 1930. When he re-worked it in 1946 he removed several references to the Congo being a Belgian colony.
But the book still contained a number of images that were
perceived as racist. One of these showed a black woman bowing to Tintin and saying White man very great...White mister is big juju man .
The book's publisher, Egmont UK, said it recognised that some readers may be offended by the content. A
This is why we took the unusual step of placing a protective band around the book with a warning about the content and also included an introduction inside the book by the original translators
explaining the historical context.
Whilst being frequently requested by fans and collectors who had seen it available in other languages, the work contains scenes which some readers may find offensive.
In his portrayal of the Belgian Congo, the young Herge' reflects the colonial attitudes of the time...
He depicted the African people according to the bourgeois, paternalistic
stereotypes of the period -- an interpretation that some of today's readers may find offensive.
|3rd November |
German church owned book store gets defensive about its erotica section
article from lifesitenews.com
In a press release, the major German publishing company Weltbild owned by the Catholic Bishops of Germany says the company is considering suing the slanderers who have accused it of profiting from porn, because the erotica sold on its
website does not meet the legal definition of pornography.
Last week media in Germany reported that the company Weltbild, owned by German dioceses and the bishops conference, carries 2,500 porn titles. The press also reported that the bishops had
ignored the pleas of Catholics who had tried to halt sales of erotic book.
Following the publication in the German media, LifeSiteNews verified that there were hundreds of erotic images, mostly book-covers, on the Weltbild site. Some of the covers
featured full frontal nudity and explicit photos typical of the covers of pornographic magazines like Playboy.
Weltbild was also found to be carrying softcore DVD's that would be deemed pornographic by Christian standards, but do not meet the
legal definition of hard-core pornography in Germany.
Since the story broke in the German media, the publishing company has been removing supposedly 'offensive' pages from its website and disabling search engine functions for searches on its
website using words such as erotic.
The bishops' company press release states that less than 0.02% of its annual turnover comes from the erotic offerings of the company and thus headlines such as Catholic Church makes a fortune with porn
are simply untrue and defamatory.
It should be noted, said Weltbild in its press release, that: 'pornography' is a clearly defined legal term. They add that according to that definition, Weltbild offers no pornography
and has never done so before.
|1st November |
Lord of Flies publisher demanded that William Goldring write out allusions to christianity
See article from
The author of a classic novel which charts the descent into savagery of a group of marooned schoolboys was ordered to remove a Christian theme from the book before it was published.
The surprising insistence of publishers editing William
Golding's seminal work Lord of the Flies has emerged in correspondence released on the centenary of the author's birth. As well as telling Golding to steer clear of Christianity, his publishers also ordered details of nuclear holocaust to be
struck from the pages.
In 1954, Golding was an author struggling to find a publisher for his first book, Lord of the Flies, an allegorical tale of civilisation crashing into barbarism. It had been rejected 10 times, including by Faber and Faber,
who then relented and finally put the book into print.
Correspondence with publishers, which have not been made public until now, forms a central part of new display at Oxford's Bodleian library. Also on display for the first time is the rejection
note from Faber which called the novel an absurd and uninteresting fantasy. Rubbish and dull .
Eventually the book was championed by a publishing executive, Charles Montieth. The letters reveal Montieth objected to what Golding called the
theophany of the novel, the appearance of God to man, and the obvious Christianity of Simon, another of the boys marooned on the island after the plane crash.
|31st October |
German catholic church owns erotic book publisher
Weltbild , Germany's largest media company, sells books, DVDs, music and more. It also happens to belong 100% to the Catholic Church. Few people knew about this connection until this month when Buchreport, a German industry newsletter,
reported that the Catholic company also sells erotica.
A Church spokesman responded to the report by claiming: Weltbild tries to prevent the distribution of possibly pornographic content. Presumably erotic novels aren't seen as
For more than 10 years, a group of Catholics has been trying to point out what is going on to Church authorities, and they are 'outraged' at the hypocrisy of the spokesman's statement. In 2008, the group sent a 70-page document to
all the bishops whose dioceses have shared ownership of Weltbild for 30 years, detailing evidence of the sale of erotic books.
Weltbild employs 6,400 people, has an annual turnover of 1.7 billion euros, and an online business in Germany second
only to Amazon. Weltbild is also Germany's leading book seller. The 2,500 erotic books in their online catalogue, including those from Blue Panther Books, an erotic book publisher owned by Weltbild, are one example. Their titles include: Anwaltshure
(Lawyer's Whore), Vo gelbar ( Fuckable ) and Schlampen-Internat (Sluts' Boarding School).
The Church also owns a 50% share in publishing company Droemer Knaur which also produces pornographic books
|26th October |
Nutter MP repeats her call to appoint the BBFC as book censors for sex education material
See article from
See parliamentary transcript from
Conservative MP Andrea Leadsom has repeated her call for sex education books to be classified by the BBFC.
Leadsom claims some of the material being taught to children as young as five is extraordinarily inappropriate . She wants books and
videos used for sex education to be given a rating by the British Board of Film Classification before they are used in schools.
During a Westminster Hall debate, Leadsom said many adults were horrified when they found out what children were
being taught about sex. She said:
I've seen cartoons of two people engaged in sexual activities with the caption 'Here are some ways mummies and daddies fit together', others depicting two cartoon characters
locked in an intimate embrace, accompanied by a vivid explanation, using sexual terminology of the act of intercourse.
As well as cartoons I've been shown a video of two people engaged in intercourse, with a child's voice over the
top, saying, 'it looks like they're having fun'.
She also wants the law changed so that parents actively have to opt in to sex lessons, rather than opt out , as is currently the case if they have objections.
Schools minister, Nick Gibb, said all sex education material used in state schools was scrutinised to ensure it set the
right tone . The education secretary had set out statutory guidelines for schools and councils to follow, he added, which would ensure that inappropriate content would not be used.
Comment: Parental Guidance
Perhaps a Sex Ed Parental Guidance certificate would read:
Suitable for children of all ages. Children are advised to consider whether the material may upset sensitive parents before showing it to them.
|26th October |
The latest Frank Miller graphic novel rattles a few cages
There is nothing subtle about Frank Miller's newest graphic novel, Holy Terror . The book opens with the quote: If you meet the infidel, kill the infidel , which Miller attributes to the islamic prophet Mohammed.
Miller is no
stranger to controversy. His stories, which include the film inspiring 300 and Sin City , regularly explore the darker corners of society amid shades of moral grey.
His latest work was originally envisioned as a Batman tale after
September 11 attacks on the US, the comic features heroes The Fixer, and thief-come-love interest, Natalie, as they join forces to stop an Al Qaeda plot on Empire City, a thinly veiled New York City.
For some, this underlines a worrying shift in
American entertainment. We are witnessing a growing industry of information and fear-mongering, and this work fits in the centre said Nihad Awad, the executive director of the Council on American-Islamic Relations. He described the work as shameful
In a post on his website dated September 23, Miller unapologetically defended Holy Terror as a piece of naked propaganda , but propaganda in a virtuous sense. Holy Terror is his contribution to the fight against terrorism.
Despite wary reviews, Holy Terror was the best-selling graphic novel in September, according to Diamond Comic Distributors.
|20th October |
Russian prosecutor seeks to ban Hare Krishna holy book on the grounds that it is extremist for belittling people of other faiths
Based on article from
Prosecutors in Tomsk are seeking through the courts to have the Russian translation of the most important work for Hare Krishna devotees, the Bhagavad-Gita As it Is , declared "extremist" and placed on the Federal List of Extremist
An 'expert' analysis completed in October 2010 by three academics at Tomsk State University, Sergei Avanesov, Valeri Svistunov and Valeri Naumov, found that the book contains signs of incitement of religious hatred and humiliation of
an individual based on gender, race, ethnicity, language, origin or attitude to religion .
The analysis claimed the book humiliated those who did not believe in or even know about Krishna or follow Krishna's teachings. It claimed that the
author propagated the exclusivity and superiority of his faith and was hostile, insulting and humiliating about other faiths [Just like any other supposedly holy book then] . It also claimed that the author called for
hostile or violent acts against women and non-Hare Krishna devotees.
This case is more than important for us - it is vital, Hare Krishna lawyer Mikhail Frolov told Forum 18: This is the most important development in the whole history of
our movement in Russia. They are trying not just to declare our book extremist, but our religious teaching also. If they succeed, our community throughout Russia could be declared extremist.
Meanwhile, an appeal court in Dagestan, while
upholding a three-year suspended prison term on Ziyavdin Dapayev, has ruled that works by the late Muslim theologian Said Nursi should be handed to the Dagestan Muslim Board for a decision on the question of the destruction of the banned books and
|14th October |
Book publisher on trial for extremist material
Ahmed Faraz distributed extremist books and DVDs with the aim of priming people for terrorism , a court has heard.
He is charged with 10 counts of disseminating terrorist publications, nine counts of having terrorist publications in
his possession, with a view to distributing them, and a further 11 counts relating to the possession of information that is likely to be useful to someone committing or preparing an act of terrorism.
He was not connected to any specific terrorist
plot, a jury at Kingston Crown Court, south west London, was told.
Max Hill QC, prosecuting, said:
This case is about the distribution of books and DVDs and other material which we say represent steps along the
road to radicalisation of Muslims to engage in violent terrorist attacks around the world, including the UK. This case is also about the ways and means by which to solidify that radicalisation and provide practical assistance for those who have been
Several of the publications distributed by this defendant did end up in the hands of individuals, many of them now notorious - or infamous - terrorists who have stood trial in English courtrooms such as this in the
last five years and are now serving long prison sentences, having been found guilty of plotting to terrorise the British public.
Faraz denies all charges. The trial is scheduled to finish in January 2012.
|4th October |
Historic comic book censorship seal taken over for fund raising purposes
See article from
See also cbldf.org
The Comic Book Legal Defense Fund has announced that it has received the intellectual property rights to the Comics Code Authority Seal of Approval in an assignment from the now-defunct Comic Magazine Association of America, which administrated the
Code since the 1950s.
CBLDF Executive Director Charles Brownstein says, As we reflect upon the challenges facing intellectual freedom during Banned Books Week, the Comics Code Seal is a reminder that it's possible for an entire creative field
to have those rights curtailed because of government, public, and market pressures. Fortunately, today comics are no longer constrained as they were in the days of the Code, but that's not something we can take for granted.
The CBLDF will take
over licensing of products bearing the Comics Code Seal, including t-shirts, providing a modest source of income for the organization's First Amendment legal work. Graphitti Designs is currently offering t-shirts with the Code Seal to benefit CBLDF.
Brownstein adds It's a progressive change that the Comics Code seal, which is yesterday's symbol of comics censorship, will now be used to raise money to protect the First Amendment challenges comics face in the future. That goal probably would
have been unimaginable to the Code's founders, who were part of a generation of comics professionals that were fleeing a witch-hunt that nearly trampled comics and any notion that they deserved any First Amendment protection.
|3rd October |
Russian church spokesman rails at books that 'romanticise perverted passions'
See article from
Russian orthodox church spokesman Vsevolod Chaplin, spokesman for the Moscow patriarchate, called for novels by Nabokov and Garcia Marquez to be banned.
Chaplin's demand that Russia's government investigate and limit the use of the books was
his church's latest attempt to impose religious norms on the Russian people.
Chaplin discussed Nabokov's Lolita and Gabriel Garcia Marquez's One Hundred Years of Solitude on Ekho Moskvy radio, accusing both of justifying
The priest later elaborated in comments carried by Interfax, saying the authors' works should not be included in high school curriculums as they romanticise perverted passions that make people unhappy . Obviously, the
popularisation of these novels in schools will not make our society more morally happy.
Mikhail Shvydkoi, a Kremlin envoy for international cultural co-operation, disagreed, saying such action by authorities would badly hurt Russia's image.
Nabokov published Lolita in English in 1955. The book, which describes a relationship of a middle-aged intellectual with his 12-year-old stepdaughter, was briefly banned in several European countries. The Colombian novelist Garcia Marquez was
awarded the Nobel Prize in literature in 1982. One Hundred Years of Solitude is a complex historical cum adult fairy tale acclaimed as a masterpiece.
|1st October |
Court hears case to ban a 1931 TinTin book
See article from
A Congolese-born campaigner has finally stated his case in court in a 4-year bid to ban a Tintin book. He is claiming that its cartoon depections of Africans are racist.
Mbutu Mondondo Bienvenu launched a legal case in 2007 against the book
Tintin in the Congo . The book was published in 1931 and he is taking action against a modern version of the original. Openly racist language was removed in subsequent editions.
What poses a problem today is not Herge, it's the
commercialisation of a cartoon book which manifestly diffuses ideas based on racial superiority, his lawyer Ahmed L'Hedim told the court.
The English language version carries a warning to readers that its contents could be offensive and that
it should be seen in the context of its time. If the court decides against an outright ban, the complainant wants a similar warning placed on the editions in French and Dutch sold in Belgium.
Moulinsart, the foundation which holds the Tintin
copyright, has refused to attach a warning. It says many works could be accused of discrimination.
Mbutu Mondondo initially brought criminal charges over the book created by Belgian author and illustrator Georges Remi, better known as Herge'.
However, after lengthy delays, his legal team started a civil case last year.
Publisher Casterman and Moulinsart will present their counter-arguments at a hearing in Brussels on 14 October, with a ruling expected in about two months.
|26th September |
Religious book on the subject of chastising children cleared by New Zealand censor
A book teaching parents how to smack, thump and pull their children's hair has been submitted to the New Zealand book censor.
The Censorship Compliance Unit assessed the book, written by fundamentalist Christians Michael and Debi Pearl, and
decided not to ban or restrict it.
A spokesman for the Department of Internal Affairs, which the office and unit belong to, said while the book was contrary to section 59 of the Crimes Act, which stated a parent or guardian could not use any force
on a child for the purpose of correction , that wasn't sufficient reason to justify restricting or banning the 20-year-old book.
The complainant could, however, ask that the Office of Film and Literature Classification also investigate the
To Train Up A Child courted controversy worldwide after a California couple who followed its instructions were convicted of murdering their seven-year-old adopted daughter.
|26th September |
A whole library of 1319 banned books
See article from
A total of 1319 books are banned in New Zealand and a further 728 are age restricted in some way. About one third of these have been listed since 1987.
Many are of a sexual nature, deal with violence, horror and crime and might have only
been fully read by one book censor in New Zealand who decided they shouldn't be available to the rest of us.
Some of the titles belonging to 'objectionable' or restricted books included Confessions of a Pimp , Horny Housewife , Inside Linda Lovelace
and A Lesbian Happening.
It was up to the Office of Film and Literature Classification and the Censorship Compliance Unit to assess books, films, DVDs and even T-shirts and determine whether they should be banned or restricted.
It has to include sex, horror, crime, cruelty or violence in some way for us to ban or restrict it, the office's advisor Michelle Baker said. Items that include offensive language and self harm, risk taking and suicide issues can't be
banned, but could be restricted.
Baker said the office hardly reviewed its decisions, unless someone requested it to do so. Books published about homosexuality before it was made legal in 1986 could have been banned at that time and remain so,
unless someone had requested they were reviewed.
Books are usually brought to the office's attention by police, customs or the public. The author, publisher, complainant and interested parties are given 14 days to make a submission, while one of
the office's 15 censors started reading the book.
Book Censorship Penalties
- A person found possessing an 'objectionable' book can be sentenced to up to five years in prison, or fined up to $50,000.
- A person who exhibited or displayed a banned book can be sentenced to up to 10 years in jail.
- Someone who made
a restricted book available to people under the age of restriction can be fined $10,000 or sentenced to three months' jail, and an organisation could be fined up to $200,000.
|22nd September |
Algiers Book Fair is missing 400 banned books
Algeria's censorship minister says 400 books were banned from the country's international book fair which has just opened.
Khalida Toumi said at a news conference that the law on importing books banned those supported colonialism, terrorism and
racism. Books attacking the national liberation struggle against France were also not allowed in.
|21st September |
By Kobus van Rooyen
Based on article from
Available at US
Amazon for release on 15th March 2012
Writer Andre P Brink, in his preface to this book, says that he had the dubious distinction of seeing his novel Kennis Van Die Aand ( Looking on Darkness ) pounced on as the first Afrikaans work of fiction to be banned ,
and then followed the censorship from the inside. He notes that as the machinations of censorship became pernicious and destructive , literature suffered. During the Seventies the Jacobsen's Index of banned publications was expanded to well more
than 20 000 titles, including hundreds of the greatest titles of world literature.
Kobus Van Rooyen takes the reader through the South African censorship history in 14 chapters. He starts with the moral clampdown (1963 to 1975) to where we are
Personally, I have no excuse for those pre-1980 times -- I cannot deny that I was involved in the decisions made, and I must confess that I was pondering whether we were not far too strict, Van Rooyen says about his initial days as
the youngest (then 33) member among older colleagues.
His endeavours in the Eighties of freeing South Africa from despotic censorship laws were diametrically opposed to conservative doctrine.
By 1985, he (as deputy dean of the law
faculty of the University of Pretoria moon-lighting as chairman of the Appeal Board) became aware of the daunting task that lay ahead of me, to free South Africa from the slavery of censorship .
However strongly autobiographical the
book is, it makes for interesting and often amusing reading about a dark period and the battle that had to be waged.
l Van Rooyen was chairman of the Publications Appeal Board from 1980 to 1990. He then served as chairman of the Press Council and
Broadcasting Complaints Commission (a position he still holds) and chaired the ministerial task group which drafted the new Films and Publications Act from 1994 to 1996.
|4th September |
Recent book censorship by US security services
See article from salon.com
|25th August |
Religious book on the subject of how to bring up kids to be examined by the New Zealand censor
See article from
A book teaching parents how to smack, thump and pull their children's hair could soon be banned in New Zealand following a complaint.
To Train Up a Child has been removed from Whitcoulls' online store but other leading book sites are still
The book, by fundamentalist United States Christians Michael and Debi Pearl, promotes using a rod, such as a branch or belt, several times on a child as a way of disciplining and training them to obey.
It has courted controversy
worldwide after a California couple who followed the book's instructions were convicted of murdering their seven-year-old adopted daughter.
The New Zealand Internal Affairs Department's Censorship Compliance Unit confirmed it was investigating the
book after a complaint was made last week.
An American child abuse victim, now living in New Zealand, complained to Whitcoulls, which agreed to remove the book from its website. The victim said he was shocked to find out the book was being sold in
New Zealand, despite the country's anti-smacking law. He said: I'm not one to prevent books from being sold, ...BUT... I think an instruction manual on how to enact violence on your child is a completely different story.
Bradford, who campaigned as a Green Party MP to remove the defence of reasonable force when disciplining a child, said she was concerned parents would buy the book and follow its instructions.
Censorship Compliance Unit manager Stephen OBrien said
the book's content would be investigated and, if it was found to be objectionable, it could be either banned, restricted or referred to the human rights or children's commissioners.
There are 1309 books already banned in New Zealand.
|25th July |
Pernod fail in an attempt to censor French book describing a culture of drinking at the company
See article from
A French court has rejected an attempt by the drinks company Pernod Ricard to censor a book that claimed potential sales staff were expected to prove they could hold their drink by knocking back glasses of pernod.
Some job applicants said they
were subject to a crash test in which they had to drink up to 20 shots before they were given the job.
The allegations are contained in the book Dealer Legal by the French journalist Max Coder, who spoke to several company employees.
The court of appeal upheld an earlier judgment that declared Coder had acted in good faith when he described how potential employees were expected to show they could hold their drink. Pernod Ricard had claimed defamation and sought Euro 500,000 in
In its defence, the company said it had published a memo to its sales staff stipulating that the excessive consumption of alcohol is not and should not be, here at Ricard, an attitude that leads to professional success .
court of appeal said this advice did not go far enough in outlining the alcohol limits and said those sued in the complaint should be given the benefit of [having acted in] good faith .
Pernod Ricard was ordered to pay EUR2,000 legal costs
to the author and co-author of Dealer Legal, the editor and a company salesperson quoted in the book.
|25th July |
Iran's supreme leader has a whinge at 'harmful' books
See article from
Iran's former culture minister, Ataollah Mohajerani, has criticised the country's supreme leader for restricting access to literature after Ayatollah Ali Khamenei publicly attacked harmful books and likened them to poisonous drugs.
meeting with librarians and officials from Iran's book industry, Khamenei spoke out against books with a cultural appearance but with specific political hidden motives. Not all books are necessarily good and not all of them are unharmful, some books
Mohajerani who was culture minister until 2000 under the reformist president Mohammad Khatami, said the ayatollah was worried about literary, philosophical and social books that might raise questions about his legitimacy as
the supreme leader. I think that he is very much concerned about books that can either implicitly or explicitly target his position as the supreme leader and also his legitimacy.
In his speech, Khamenei, whose pronouncements are often
interpreted as official guidelines, refused to give more details on which books he deemed harmful . However, titles ranging from uncensored version of Plato's Symposium to Louis-Ferdinand Celine's Journey to the End of the Night and
works by James Joyce, Gabriel Garcia Marquez, Kurt Vonnegut and Paulo Coelho have been banned in recent years by Iran's ministry of culture and Islamic guidance which vets all books before publication:
responsible in the book industry should not let harmful books enter our book market on the basis that we let them [readers] choose [what they want to read].
Like poisonous, dangerous and addictive drugs which are not
available for everyone without restrictions ... as a publisher, librarian or an official in the book industry, we don't have the right to make [such books] available to those without knowledge, he said. We should provide them with healthy and good books.
His comments stem from a traditional clerical mentality that clerics guide people as shepherds guide their sheep, this is a viewpoint that doesn't have any place in
|24th June |
Book burning protests against Lawrence Hill's The Book of Negroes
article from vancouversun.com
The Dutch group Federation for Honour and Reparation of Slavery in Surinam has made a book burning protest against Toronto author Lawrence Hill's award-winning novel The Book of Negroes . However, instead of burning the entire book, the group
has only burned its cover.
CBC News reported that the group chose to only burn the cover because their protest regards the title of the novel, and specifically its use of the word negro, which they deem offensive.
chair of The Writers' Union of Canada, said in a press release:
The burning of books represents censorship at its worst. While we recognize the sensitivity over the use of the word 'Negro' in the book's title, The
Book of Negroes is a real document and Mr. Hill uses it deliberately to underscore the plight of African Americans being shipped from New York to Nova Scotia in 1783.
When the novel was published in the United States the title
was changed to Somebody Knows My Name .
|14th June |
Pakistan apparently bans book about Al Qaeda and the Taliban
See article from
Pakistan's government has imposed an unannounced ban on a book written by slain journalist Syed Saleem Shahzad.
The book, Inside Al-Qaida and the Taliban, Beyond Bin Laden and 9/11 , is unavailable at all leading book stores, with the shop
owners saying its sales had been banned by the government.
Pakistan Today contacted the publishers, Pluto Press of London, to inquire about the ban. Pluto Press' Sales Director Simon Liebesny said via e-mail that they could not deliver any statement
in the current situation as their shipment for Pakistan was under process with the UK Customs.
Pluto Press said the book was launched on May 20, 2011. It wrote in the description of the book that:
has delivered on his campaign promise to kill Osama bin Laden, but as an al Qaeda strategist, bin Laden has been dead for years. This book introduces the new generation of al Qaeda leaders who have been behind the most recent attacks. Shahzad, an
investigative reporter, had a level of access to al Qaeda and the Taliban that Western journalists could only dream of. He had interviewed many top-level strategists and fighters in both movements on multiple occasions in Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan and
Jordan. In Inside Al-Qaeda and the Taliban he uses first-hand accounts and his own local knowledge to build up a convincing and compelling picture of the aims and motivation of the leaders and fighters in radical movements. This is a version of the war
on terror that has never been told. It will fascinate anyone concerned with the strategy and tactics of the most controversial Islamic movements.
|5th May |
Anime ebooks banned from Amazon
Based on article from
Recently Amazon has become more strict in enforcing their content requirements for ebooks.
Several Digital Manga books that have been available online since 2009 are getting the axe, beginning with our 801 Media titles like Weekend Lovers and
King of Debt . However, in the last few days the issue has spread to the June imprint by Amazon's refusal of The Selfish Demon King , and the removal of The Color of Love from the Kindle store.
We fear that Amazon may target
more of our books for removal so we're warning all Amazon Kindle store users that providing you with our content may become more difficult in the future.
|28th April |
Censored texts restored to Oscar Wilde's novel
See article from telegraph.co.uk
An uncensored version of Oscar Wilde's only novel, The Picture of Dorian Gray , has finally been published.
JM Stoddart, Wilde's editor, made a number of alterations to downplay the overt homoeroticism in the novel before it appeared in
Lippincott's Monthly Magazine in June 1890.
He also removed references to the protagonist's female lovers as mistresses , and withdrew other sections that smacked of decadence , according to Nicholas Frankel, the editor of the new,
But his efforts did not go far enough, and following its publication more passages were removed, The Guardian reported.
One section reading It is quite true I have worshipped you with far more romance of feeling than a
man should ever give to a friend was changed to: From the moment I met you, your personality had the most extraordinary influence on me .
Frankel said it was time to published the uncensored text, claiming he hoped to bring it out of
the closet for a 21st century audience.
|7th April |
Censored scenes restored to the novel From Here to Eternity
See article from
An original version of 1951 novel From Here to Eternity is to be reissued digitally, with previously censored references to homosexuality restored.
The heirs of author James Jones have struck a deal with an ebook firm to put out a new
edition that includes two scenes with gay content.
The uncensored version will be released online from 10 May.
It will include a scene in which Private Angelo Maggio reveals he is paid to have oral sex with another man.
referring to a military investigation into possible homosexual activity will also feature in the text.
The restored version will also include profanity that was considered too extreme for Eternity's original publisher Scribner.
|1st April |
Indian state considers a law against supposed insult against Gandhi
Based on article from
Outrage over reviews of new Gandhi book from
Even as the Gujarat government banned the book on Mahatma Gandhi by Joseph Lelyveld that has run into controversy for references suggesting he was a bisexual and a racist, the Centre is now mulling a law that would make showing any disrespect to the
Father of the Nation an offence punishable with a jail term.
Sources in the Law Ministry said the ministry had been asked to suggest amendment to the Prevention of Insults to National Honour Act, 1971, so as to make any action or gesture that
shows disrespect to Gandhi an offence at par with an offence against the National Flag or the Constitution.
|28th February |
Book censorship relaxed in post revolution Tunisia
Tunisian bookshops changed dramatically after the January 14th revolution swept former President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali from power. Books that were once banned and covertly brought into the country are now being displayed freely.
find a copy of La Régente de Carthage which exposes the corruption and influence of Leila Ben Ali on Tunisian political and economic life, student Suha Bin Mustapha told Magharebia at the El-Kitab bookstore in Tunis: I am now making
a request to reserve a copy that the owner said would be available by the end of the month.
Tunisia's interim government on January 22nd lifted licensing restrictions on the importation of books, publications and films, opening the floodgates
to foreign media. The constraints were imposed by the Ben Ali regime to control the flow of information.
Lifting restrictions on importing books is a key demand that has been called on by voices of enlightenment, modernity and the democracy of
culture and knowledge in Tunisia, said Moktar Kalfaoui, a writer for the website Alawan.
In the past, possessing these books meant persecution, losing a job, or even imprisonment, according to bookstore customer Nora.
In previous years,
the Tunisian International Book Fair earned a poor reputation because of strict censorship imposed on imported works, forcing exhibitors to focus on cookbooks and fiction.
The Tunisian culture ministry used to claim that it only prohibited books
that promoted religious extremism and terrorism. But there were several complaints from Arab and foreign publishers regarding the ban on political themes. In the end, many just didn't bother to attend the fair.
|22nd January |
DC comics opts out of a historic morality code in favour of its own self rating scheme
Based on article
After nearly sixty years, DC Comics has decided that none of its publications need carry the Seal of Approval of the Comics Code Authority.
The announcement was made in a communique to direct market retailers, which also included the news that
DC will employ a new ratings system of its own design. Deployment of DC's new ratings system will begin in April.
The new self rating scheme is described as follows:
Appropriate for readers of all ages. May contain cartoon violence and/or some comic mischief.
Appropriate for readers age 12 and older. May contain mild
violence, language and/or suggestive themes.
T+: TEEN PLUS
Appropriate for readers age 16 and older. May contain moderate violence, mild profanity, graphic imagery and/or suggestive
Appropriate for readers age 18 and older. May contain intense violence, extensive profanity, nudity, sexual themes and other content suitable only for older
The Comics Code Authority
The previous moralistic code was established in 1954 after moral panics of the era.
General Standards Part A
- Crimes shall never be presented in such a way as to create sympathy for the criminal, to promote distrust of the forces of law and justice, or to inspire others with a desire to imitate criminals.
No comics shall explicitly present the unique details and methods of a crime.
- Policemen, judges, government officials, and respected institutions shall never be presented in such a way as to
create disrespect for established authority.
- If crime is depicted it shall be as a sordid and unpleasant activity.
- Criminals shall not be presented so as to be rendered glamorous
or to occupy a position which creates the desire for emulation.
- In every instance good shall triumph over evil and the criminal punished for his misdeeds.
- Scenes of excessive
violence shall be prohibited. Scenes of brutal torture, excessive and unnecessary knife and gun play, physical agony, gory and gruesome crime shall be eliminated.
- No unique or unusual methods of concealing weapons
shall be shown.
- Instances of law enforcement officers dying as a result of a criminal's activities should be discouraged.
- The crime of kidnapping shall never be portrayed in any
detail, nor shall any profit accrue to the abductor or kidnapper. The criminal or the kidnapper must be punished in every case.
- The letter of the word crime on a comics magazine shall never be appreciably
greater than the other words contained in the title. The word crime shall never appear alone on a cover.
- Restraint in the use of the word crime in titles or sub-titles shall be exercised.
General Standards Part B
- No comics magazine shall use the word horror or terror in its title.
- All scenes of horror, excessive bloodshed, gory or gruesome crimes, depravity, lust, sadism, masochism shall not be
- All lurid, unsavory, gruesome illustrations shall be eliminated.
- Inclusion of stories dealing with evil shall be used or shall be published only where the intent is to
illustrate a moral issue and in no case shall evil be presented alluringly nor as to injure the sensibilities of the reader.
- Scenes dealing with, or instruments associated with walking dead, torture, vampires and
vampirism, ghouls, cannibalism and werewolfism are prohibited.
General Standards Part C
- 1Profanity, obscenity, smut, vulgarity, or words or symbols which have acquired undesirable meanings are forbidden.
- Special precautions to avoid references to physical afflictions of
deformities shall be taken.
- Although slang and colloquialisms are acceptable, excessive use should be discouraged and wherever possible good grammar shall be employed.
Ridicule or attack on any religious or racial group is never permissible.
- Nudity in any form is prohibited, as is indecent or undue exposure.
- Suggestive and salacious illustration or suggestive posture is unacceptable.
characters shall be depicted in dress reasonably acceptable to society.
- Females shall be drawn realistically without exaggeration of any physical qualities.
Marriage and Sex:
- Divorce shall not be treated humorously nor represented as desirable.
- Illicit sex relations are neither to be hinted at or portrayed. Violent love scenes as well as sexual abnormalities are
- Respect for parents, the moral code, and for honorable behavior shall be fostered. A sympathetic understanding of the problems of love is not a license for moral distortion.
The treatment of love-romance stories shall emphasize the value of the home and the sanctity of marriage.
- Passion or romantic interest shall never be treated in such a way as to stimulate the
lower and baser emotions.
- Seduction and rape shall never be shown or suggested. Sex perversion or any inference to same is strictly forbidden.
The code was updated over the years to allow for the depiction of werewolves, vampires, the corruption of elected officials, and gays of which the taboo itself became taboo.
|4th January |
Huckleberry Finn published with the word 'nigger' replaced by 'slave'
Mark Twain's Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is a classic . Yet, for decades, it has been disappearing from grade school curricula across the country, relegated to optional reading lists, or banned outright, appearing again and again on
lists of the nation's most challenged books, and all for its repeated use of a single word: nigger.
Twain scholar Alan Gribben and NewSouth Books now plan to release a version of Huckleberry Finn , in a single volume with The
Adventures of Tom Sawyer , that does away with the word 'nigger' by replacing it with the word slave. It also replaces the word Injun .
This is not an effort to render Tom Sawyer and Huckleberry Finn colorblind, said
Gribben: Race matters in these books. It's a matter of how you express that in the 21st century.