A Los Angeles County Superior Court judge has dismissed a petition seeking a court order to compel county public health officials to require
condom use on porn sets or take other reasonable steps to stem the spread of disease.
The petition, filed by the AIDS Healthcare Foundation, contended that the Los Angeles County Department of Public Health has passively observed an ever-growing epidemic within the porn industry.
Words alone cannot fight disease, the petition said. For over a decade, county health officials have talked, watched, written and analyzed. What county health officials have not done is act.
Judge David P. Yaffe rejected the petition, noting that the county has broad discretion in how it oversees public health.
The AIDS advocacy group sued the county in July. The action came weeks after an adult-film actress tested positive for HIV and county health officials released data that showed 18 HIV cases and more than 3,700 cases of chlamydia, gonorrhea and syphilis
had been reported since 2004 by a San Fernando Valley-based clinic that mainly serves the porn industry. Adult Industry Medical Healthcare Foundation officials said at the time that the majority of the cases did not involve working adult film performers.
AIDS Healthcare Foundation officials plan to appeal the decision and said they would press for change. We just hope the county will do the right thing without being compelled to do it by a court, foundation President Michael Weinstein said. This is going to be a years-long battle and it's going to have its ups and downs, but we know in the end that public health is going to win.
The owner of a brothel more than two hours' drive from Las Vegas said she hopes to hire Nevada's first legal male prostitutes
within a month, now that state health officials have approved a method to test men for infectious diseases.
The world is ready for women, or even other men, to legally buy sex, said Shady Lady Ranch owner Bobbi Davis. Plus, being the first to offer male service could boost business in tough economic times, she said.
With so many other male revues going on in Vegas, we thought it was time to give this a try, Davis told The Associated Press.
Until now, men have been effectively barred from legally plying the world's oldest profession in Nevada by the specificity of a state health law requiring prostitutes to undergo frequent cervical testing for sexually transmitted diseases. The health
board approved a regulation to allow urethral testing for men — a crucial rule change by the state agency with ultimate power over whether prostitutes can or can't work.
The brothel still needs county approval. Nye County Sheriff Tony DeMeo said: We're going to look at it. We have some concerns. The ramifications of this are going to be statewide . We're going to have to deal with it at our other six brothels
in Nye County if they want to offer the same service. We want to make sure we protect customers and make sure the industry is regulated with clarity and understanding.
Davis said she wants to add two men to the three women she currently has living and working at her compound of trailers off U.S. 95 about 150 miles northwest of Las Vegas. She said the women usually charge about $300 per hour for the five to 20 customers
who visit on any given night. We don't know how to structure the men's pricing yet, Davis said.
Despite a highly trumpeted New York State law in 2007 that enacted tough penalties for sex or labor trafficking, very few people have
been prosecuted since it went into effect, according to state statistics.
In New York State, there have been 18 arrests and one conviction for trafficking since the law was signed by Gov. Eliot Spitzer and took effect in November 2007, according to the New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services. There is one case
pending in Manhattan, one in Queens and two in the Bronx.
The situation is not all that different in New Jersey or in roughly 30 states that have laws against human trafficking — defined as using fraud or force to exploit a person for sex or labor. A federal law passed in 2000 with lifetime prison penalties has
resulted in 196 cases with convictions against 419 people, according to statistics from the United States Department of Justice.
The scale of those numbers contrasts starkly with the 14,500 to 17,500 people the State Department estimates are brought into the United States each year for forced labor or sex.
The Utah Supreme Court has ruled that a state tax on strip clubs is constitutional but that the same tax on escort services is not.
Passed in 2004, the tax levies a statewide 10% tax on admission and user fees charged by sexually-explicit businesses, defined as any business where a nude or partially denuded employee or contractor performs any service. Utah-produced
merchandise, food and drinks sold by these businesses also are subject to the tax.
The statute also levies a tax on escort services, which are defined as any person who furnishes or arranges for an escort who is compensated to accompany another individual for companionship. An escort is any individual who is available to the
public for the purpose of accompanying another individual for compensated companionship.
Associate Chief Justice Matthew B. Durrant said that the state's Sexually Explicit Business and Escort Service Tax is content-neutral when applied to nudity.
In this case, application of the tax is triggered by nudity, which the Supreme Court has specifically declared 'is not an inherently expressive condition, Durrant wrote. Because it is not inherently expressive, nudity is unprotected conduct
rather than protected expression.
Regarding the taxing of escort services, Durrant found that the language was fatally overbroad, but opened the door to a legislative revision that included more specific language. Nowhere does the statute define an escort in terms of nudity, he
wrote. The statute also fails to define the term 'companionship.' Therefore, according to the plain terms of the statute, individuals who are paid for providing care for the elderly as well as those who are paid as tour guides would fall within the
definition of an 'escort,' and any person or business who employs them would be subject to the tax.
The nutter sheriff of Cook County, Illinois, is taking a page from the Swedish welfare state in revising his approach to prostitution.
Loudly applauding his eight-month-old experiment is End Demand Illinois (EDI), a coalition of nonprofits that aims to extend the reform statewide and eventually see it replicated across the country.
What Sheriff Tom Dart has done is shift enforcement resources from the supply side to the demand side: from arresting (and releasing and re-arresting) women and girls to arresting pimps and customers and impounding their cars, while directing the
prostituted females to social services.
Last week a U.S. district judge threw out another part of Dart's new strategy: a lawsuit against Craigslist for the hazard created by its online want ads offering erotic and adult services-.
A female baseball fan has been charged after allegedly offering her body in exchange for sought-after tickets to the World Series.
Susan Finkelstein, 43, from Philadelphia, was arrested after meeting an undercover policeman in a suburban bar with the intention, it is claimed, of exchanging sex for admission to a finals game between her beloved Phillies and the New York Yankees.
It follows an advert placed on internet site Craigslist which her lawyer admits may have included a couple of double entendres but fell way short of prostitution. William Brennan described his client as a nice lady overcome with Phillies fever .
As to the advert he said: If someone read into that posting a sexual connotation, that's on them. There's no overt sexual reference.
The online ad led to a rendezvous between Finkelstein and an undercover police officer snitch. Over a few beers she told the man that she needed two tickets, one for herself and one for her husband. Before prices were discussed she was arrested by
several officers on a nearby table and subsequently charged with the misdemeanour charge of promoting prostitution.
Finkelstein has protested that this was not what she intended. I was hoping to get cheap tickets, she told local station WPVI-TV, adding: Maybe meet someone, and talk, and bat my eyelashes and maybe get some tickets.
But there was a silver lining for the Phillies fan. A local radio station and car dealer took pity on her plight, offering a pair of tickets for a weekend game in the process.
Rhode Island Senate lawmakers have approved the bill to make prostitution a misdemeanor offense regardless of where it
occurs. Prostitutes would face a maximum six-month prison sentence for a first offense, while their customers could face up to a year.
The bill now goes to the state Governor for approval into law.
Rhode Island is the only state, besides parts of Nevada, that currently allows indoor prostitution. More than two dozen brothels are now operating across the state.
A federal judge has summarily dismissed a lawsuit Chicago's sheriff brought against Craigslist, ruling that the website can't be
sued for prostitution ads posted by its users.
The decision is a blow to Thomas Dart, the sheriff of Illinois's Cook County, who argued the erotic services section of Craigslist violated prostitution laws because it arranges meetings and directs people to places where sex is
sold. Dart sought a court order requiring the site to close the section and to pay the costs his department incurred in cracking down on hookers and Johns who used the it.
The ruling by US District Judge John F. Grady is good news not only for Craigslist but for any US-based website that accepts comments, photos, or other types of user-submitted content. The decision made it clear that a provision in the CDA, or
Communications Decency Act, fully immunizes the site for user-supplied ads even when they provide contact details for prostitutes and brothels.
Craigslist does not 'provide' that information, its users do, Grady wrote. 'Facilitating' and 'assisting' encompass a broader range of conduct, so broad in fact that they include the services provided by intermediaries like phone
companies, ISPs, and computer manufacturers. Intermediaries are not culpable for 'aiding and abetting' their customers who misuse their services to commit unlawful acts.
A movement to make porn films condom-only is sure to gain further traction as two groups plan to protest the Marriott hotel
The AIDS Healthcare Foundation and Pink Cross Foundation claim Marriott acts as a middleman in selling condom-less porn productions because it makes millions from the pay-per-view lineup it offers in its hotel rooms.
The groups are planning a Porn In at the downtown Los Angeles Marriott. They also will announce a viral and print ad campaign for a hotel boycott.
They will protest in front of the Figueroa Street Marriott with banners and three-foot wide condoms. Later, a press conference will be held in a hotel room with streaming porn on the room's flat screen.
Michael Weinstein, president of AIDS Healthcare Foundation, said that until he gets a commitment from Marriott officials to block condomless adult films to their hotel guests he will urge a public boycott of the entire Marriott chain, which
pencils out to about 3,000.
We want to highlight the brazen hypocrisy — the Mormon Marriott's moral masquerade — of such a so-called family oriented hotel chain profiteering off adult films that endanger the lives of the performers acting in them, Weinstein said.
The AIDS Healthcare Foundation has taken a stand after an adult performer tested positive for HIV several months ago.
In passing a new ordinance that requires adult businesses to be more than 2,500 feet from schools, parks, churches,
bars and residential areas, the Orlando city council has sent this message to adult businesses interested in moving to the central Florida city best known as the home to Disney World: Don't bother.
The message is not only legislative but verbal. We're a little more picky about what types of businesses we want in Orlando, Mayor Buddy Dyer said, with the clear if ungrammatical implication that Orlando is more serious about addressing
the adult entertainment issue than other townships.
With an estimated population just over 225,000, Orlando currently claims only one adult business within its city limits, Fairvilla Megastore.
The vote by the city commissioners was 6-1. Even before the vote was taken, Dyer, anticipating passage, enthused about how effective it would be. I'd be willing to bet we do not see another adult entertainment establishment open in Orlando,
based on the very restrictive ordinance we're about to pass, he said.
According to the Orlando Sentinel, the city's newly strengthened law, which also requires prospective adult businesses to now apply for a permit or license, is intended to keep adult businesses out without triggering a lawsuit alleging
In another indicator that the downturn in adult entertainment is global in nature, Private Media Group, one of only a handful of adult companies that is publicly traded, said it had received a letter on Sept. 15 from the Nasdaq Stock Market stating that
for the previous 30 consecutive business days, the bid price of the Company's common stock closed below the minimum $1 per share requirement for continued inclusion on The Nasdaq Global Market.
Private will have 180 calendar days, or until March 15, 2010, to regain compliance with the Minimum Bid Price Rule.
On the 16th September Video Classics X (VCX) is celebrating the 30th anniversary of Debbie Does Dallas with the release of the Definitive Collector's Edition of director Jim Clark's classic adult film starring Bambi Woods as cheerleader
The VCX double-disc edition won a 2008 AVN Award for Best Classic DVD, and the movie itself made history as one of the most iconic and controversial adult films of all time – inspiring lawsuits from the Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders, some graphic footnotes
in the 1986 Attorney General's Commission on Pornography. It went on to become one of the most lucrative movies of all time in its long second life as a video rental hit.
Alabama Supreme Court justices,ruled 7-2 that Love Stuff can't sell vibrators and other sexual devices.
The decision upholds the state's anti-obscenity law, with justices stating that public morality can still serve as a legitimate rational basis for regulating commercial activity, which is not a private activity.
Love Stuff, in its appeal to the Supreme Court, had claimed the state law banning the sale of sexual aides was unconstitutional and that it its unconstitutionally vague.
The justices, in their ruling quoted the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in a similar 2004 case, Williams vs. Attorney General of Alabama. In that case, plaintiffs seeking to sell sex toys and novelties were seeking to enjoin enforcement of the
state's anti-obscenity statute.
As the 11th Circuit in Williams pithily and somewhat coarsely stated: 'There is nothing 'private' or 'consensual' about the advertising and sale of a dildo, the justices said.
A federal appeals court, ruling that the city of Indianapolis has failed to offer evidence supporting tighter restrictions for adult video and bookstores, has struck down the city's six-year-old ordinance that broadens the definition of an adult
The 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, in its decision, said that the city's ordinance was flawed from the get-go because it mixed all adult establishments, including those that involve public booths, into one lump category.
If there is more misconduct at a bar than at an adult emporium, how would that justify greater legal restrictions on the bookstore — much of whose stock in trade is constitutionally protected in a way that beer and liquor are not, the court said
in its ruling: Indianapolis has approached this case by assuming that any empirical study of morals offenses near any kind of adult establishment in any city justifies every possible kind of legal restriction in every city.
The 7th Circuit added that Indianapolis city leaders failed to offer an iota of evidence supporting stricter regulations on adult book and video stores.
The six-year-old ordinance expanded the definition of an adult business to include any retailer that devotes at least 25% of its space or inventory to adult books, magazines, films and sex toys. The new definition also covered retailers who earned at
least 25% of their sales from adult items. The threshold was 50% before 2003.
The revised ordinance also made it necessary for adult entertainment businesses to be permitted for a license, and imposed rules on lighting and cleanliness. Adult entertainment businesses also were ordered closed on Sundays and after midnight on all
The city weakly justified its restrictions on the ground that they can reduce prostitution, stealing, masturbation in private booths and other crimes associated with adult businesses.
Twentieth Century Fox has sent a cease and desist letter to Digital Sin/New Sensations, which is currently in post production on a parody of its television series X-Files .
The adult studio's X-rated drama, set to release in late September, was given the title The X-Files: A Dark XXX Parody.
In the letter, a representative from Fox demands that Digital Sin/New Sensations change the title of the film and cease use of the X-Files mark.
Digital Sin/New Sensations does not believe that its intended product infringes the rights of Fox. However, in the spirit of cooperation, the company has decided to respond to Fox's concerns by adapting the title to The Sex Files: A Dark XXX Parody
, removing the website associated with the film and changing the names of the main characters.
The adult studio has successfully parodied a growing list of the primetime lineups from current and past, with spoofs of The Office , Scrubs , Seinfeld , Friends and 30 Rock resulting in sales that have given a
heartbeat to an otherwise slumping industry.
At least five of the 100 top websites in the U.S. are portals for free pornography, referred to in the industry as "tube sites," according to Internet traffic ranking service Alexa .com. Some of their content is amateur work uploaded by users
and some is acquired from cheap back catalogs, but much of it is pirated.
Sites like Pornhub, YouPorn and RedTube attract more users than TMZ and the Huffington Post. The porn sites are even bigger than Pirate Bay, the top portal for illegal downloads of movies, TV shows and music.
The adult entertainment business, which was previously in the vanguard of home video, satellite and cable television and digital distribution, now finds itself leading the rest of the entertainment industry in losses from them.
The death of the DVD business has been more accelerated in the adult business than mainstream, said Bill Asher, co-chairman of adult industry giant Vivid Entertainment, who estimates that his company's revenue is down more than 20% this year.
We always said that once the Internet took off, we'd be OK, he added. It never crossed our minds that we'd be competing with people who just give it away for free.
An AIDS advocacy group has filed complaints with state officials against 16 production companies that show unprotected sex in porn movies.
The AIDS Healthcare Foundation filed the action with the California Division of Occupational Safety and Health (CalOSHA), alleging the practice amounts to unsafe behavior in a California workplace.
We will not stop until there is a policy of requiring condoms to be used in porn, foundation president Michael Weinstein said.
By law, U.S. adult film actors must prove they have tested negative for HIV and other sexually transmitted diseases within 30 days of going to work on a film.
CalOSHA spokesman Dean Fryer said the regulatory agency requires workers in any industry where there is a possibility of transmission of fluids, including health care and adult films, to reduce the risk of disease transmission.
The employers of porn actors are required to provide a safe and healthy work environment, Fryer said.
Nearly 60 adult DVDs accompany the complaints against Hustler Video, Maverick Entertainment, Vivid and other porn production companies in Los Angeles. Many people in the multibillion-dollar industry oppose the use of condoms in the films.
Hustler publisher Larry Flynt told The Associated Press, people who enjoy viewing adult films do not want to see people using condoms.
A group of 50 professors has signed a letter urging Rhode Island lawmakers not to ban indoor prostitution.
Rhode Island is the only state in the country besides several counties in Nevada where indoor prostitution is legal.
In a letter, George Washington University professor Ronald Weitzer and Nassau Community College professor Elizabeth Wood said prostitutes who work indoors are less likely to be assaulted, raped or robbed. They said treating indoor and outdoor
prostitution differently is a step in the right direction.
Rhode Island House and Senate lawmakers have backed sharply different bills that would ban indoor prostitution. They are trying to reach a compromise before a vote expected in September.
Barry Goldman, who operates Torture Portal, Masters of Pain and Bacchus Studios, has been charged by a federal grand jury
in Newark, N.J. with distributing obscene DVDs through the mail.
Goldman was charged with eight counts of sending DVDs containing allegedly obscene films from Jersey City to addresses in Montana and Virginia.
The indictments for 18 U.S.C. § 1461 and § 1467 include the films Torture of a Porn Store Girl , Defiant Crista Submits and Pregnant and Willing . The videos all were mailed in 2006 and 2007.
The Justice Department is seeking forfeitures of all copies of the movies, as well as proceeds from the sale of the movies.
Regulators also are seeking the forfeitures of domain names MastersOfPain.com and TorturePortal.com, as well as an email address, SirBNY@aol.com.
Bonnie Hannon, the Justice Department's lead attorney in the case works for the agency's Criminal Division's Obscenity Prosecution Task Force. Investigation of the case was conducted by the FBI's Adult Obscenity Squad based at the Washington field
The obscenity case, originally filed in Montana, was changed to New Jersey, according to an XBIZ source. But in the midst of the appeal, the government dismissed the case, claiming it is not their policy to file obscenity charges in the place of
receipt in the absence of other contacts by the defendant with the place of prosecution.
If convicted, Goldman faces a maximum penalty of five years in prison and a fine of $250,000 on each of the eight counts charged in the indictment.
Craigslist has been accused of returning old ways, running thinly veiled sex-for-hire ads and sparking a new round of 'outrage'
from law enforcement.
Ads posted on the Internet giant have replaced pornographic photos and explicit sexual language with shots of scantily clad women tantalizing would-be customers with love it like it's your last . . . have some fun with this sexy, attractive,
vibrant young lady. My measurements are . . .
Suffolk District Attorney Daniel F. Conley ripped the Web site, saying its new adult services ads are basically no different than the old erotic services come-ons: A cursory look at the adult services section of the site shows no
significant distinction from the 'erotic services' section that preceded it, Conley told the Herald.
In Illinois, Cook County Sheriff Thomas Dart, a staunch Craigslist critic, said the new revamped site has changed little from the old raunchy one. To say I've been less than overwhelmed by Craigslist's new practices would be an understatement,
Dart told the Herald.
In May, the site announced a crackdown on ads, ordering his employees to censor them for graphic sexual content.
Now instead of appearing naked, women advertising adult services are pictured wearing bikinis and lingerie. And they rely on innuendo - and the user's familiarity with Craigslist - to get their message across.
The site now runs ads such as Upscale European Beauty Ready to Play and all natural 40f's ... no disappointments and Let's have some late night fun!
A California bill that would have imposed a 20% tax on sales of adult movies and sex toys, as well as the receipts of
strip clubs, has been voted down by a legislative panel. The bill was voted down in the Assembly Tax and Revenue Committee.
California Assemblywoman Mary Salas, D-San Diego, sponsored the proposal, which would have sent revenue from the tax to a newly created Adult Venue Impact Fund.
The fund would then have been distributed to local law enforcement agencies in an effort to deal with secondary effects that are supposedly associated with adult entertainment businesses.
Salas' chief of staff, Francisco Estrada, told XBIZ that the assemblywoman was deeply disappointed by the 5-4 vote against the bill: At this point, we're not sure if the bill will be resurrected .
Rob Zicari better known as Rob Black and his wife Janet Romano (stage name Lizzie Borden) were each sentenced to one year and one
day in federal prison after pleading guilty to once count of conspiracy to distribute obscene materials last March.
As part of the guilty plea, Zicari and Romano admitted that through the parent company of XPW, Extreme Associates, Inc., they mailed three obscene movies to Pennsylvania, where this whole thing started.
The movies that essentially brought down the company were Forced Entry - Director's Cut, Cocktails 2 - Directors Cut , and Extreme Teen #24 .
They also got in hot water for distributing the material through Internet streams.
As part of of their plea agreement the couple was also sentenced to a two year probationary term upon their release from prison.
The owner of the Chicken Ranch claims that he's trying to sell the legal Nevada brothel, but Nye County officials won't let him
because they are trying to rid the county of its legal brothels by attrition.
Chicken Ranch President Kenneth Green, in the suit filed at U.S. District Court in Las Vegas, points to several incidences where Nye County Board of Commissioners overstepped their authority overseeing the county's legal brothel system.
Green said that after Texas resident Bruce Kahn made a deposit to buy the Chicken Ranch in 2006, he was able to walk away because the board denied Kahn's application to run the brothel because he was not a resident of Nevada six months prior to
Green also accused Nye County officials of refusing to allow the transfer of the license to Debbie Rivenburgh, who oversees the brothel's daily operations, because she did not have enough personal funds to operate the Chicken Ranch on her own
despite guaranteed financial backing.
Government officials have virtual unfettered discretion in all licensing matters concerning legal brothels and are using such assumed unfettered discretion to attempt to rid the county of its legal brothels by attrition, the complaint
Green is seeking declaratory judgment, an injunction permitting the sale and punitive damages.
U.S. District Judge Julie Robinson has temporarily stopped the state of Kansas from enforcing a law restricting roadside signs
for adult stores.
The judge issued the preliminary injunction sought by Lion's Den Adult Superstore in Abilene, Kansas after hearing arguments.
Lion's Den has been trying to overturn the state law, which would become effective July 1 and require the company to remove outdoor advertising within a mile of a state highway.
Representatives at the Kansas attorney general's office called the decision unfortunate and said it would evaluate its options. The attorney general was sued in federal court by the parent company of Lions Den on grounds that the law violated the
A California bill that would impose a 20% tax on sales of adult movies and sex toys, as well as the receipts of strip
clubs, has been introduced in the Legislature.
California Assemblywoman Mary Salas introduced the proposal, which would send revenue from the tax to a newly created Adult Venue Impact Fund.
The fund would then be distributed to local law enforcement agencies in an effort to deal with supposed secondary effects that are associated with adult entertainment businesses.
Free Speech Coalition lobbyist Ignacio Hernandez said the bill could be found unconstitutional on several points, including taxation based on the content of a movie: This measure is clearly unconstitutional and unworkable. This bill is much
broader than previous efforts to tax adult movie and novelty retailers. Therefore, it suffers from greater constitutional defects than prior bills.
Hernandez said the broad definition of harmful material included in the bill's language would likely be opposed by entertainment organizations like the Motion Picture Association of America.
Specifically, Assembly Bill 847 would levy a 20% on the gross receipts of any California business that is:
A retail establishment whose gross receipts from the sale or rental of adult material exceeds 50% of all gross receipts.
Providing a public or private viewing of adult material.
An establishment that offers live sexually explicit conduct that is prohibited to audiences under 18 years of age or 21 years of age, depending on whether alcoholic beverages are sold on the premises.
A hearing on the latest proposed porn tax bill is scheduled for next month.
A federal judge has upheld Ohio laws banning strip club patrons from touching dancers and limiting hours for strip clubs that serve
A group of adult entertainment owners and the Buckeye Association of Club Executives, a trade group that represents cabarets and adult bookstores, had sued at U.S. District Court in October 2007 seeking to have the law declared unconstitutional.
Judge Solomon Oliver Jr. granted motions by local government attorneys to have the suit dismissed. Oliver found that the state law that bans exotic dancers and customers from touching each other does not violate 1st Amendment or other
constitutional rights of the business owners. Oliver also upheld the state law that limits the hours of operation for adult clubs that serve liquor.
Oliver disagreed with claims from club owners that the no touch law violated freedom of speech guarantees, and also disagreed with arguments that the ban is overly broad and could be applied to ballet dancers or other mainstream theatrical
The Detroit City Council is expected to consider a broad nutter inspired crackdown that would ban alcohol at clubs that offer topless
Strip club owners are vowing a fight. Rob Katzman, owner of the Toy Chest Bar and Grille, says the potential changes would put nearly all of the clubs out of business.
Detroit has about 30 topless bars. The crackdown stems from a court battle in which a federal judge in 2007 struck down Detroit's regulations on where clubs could open and ordered them rewritten.
City staffers have recast the laws in consultation with a Tennessee anti-strip club attorney.
A panel of City Council members got their first peek Wednesday at the proposals. The panel took no action, but a majority of members appeared to have issues with revised ordinances that would stop lap dancing, close VIP rooms and force dancers to
wear opaque pasties -- even at dry clubs.
Members Martha Reeves, Kenneth Cockrel Jr., Sheila Cockrel, Monica Conyers and Alberta Tinsley-Talabi all expressed problems with the alcohol ban.
Several worried it would invite more lawsuits from the clubs. There are all kinds of people in this world, Reeves said: The first thing in my mind when I read this ... was it was written by a minister.
Pastors and nutter leaders have pushed for the changes. Despite the ban's chilly reception Wednesday, it appears some in the religious community will continue to push it. Richard Mack, a member of Perfecting Church who has been vocal on the issue,
said what I see, I like.
OUTBREAK! 16 ADULT FILM STARS TEST POSITIVE FOR HAVING HIV! screamed the headline on MediaTakeOut.com — and its lead paragraph wasn't much better,
claiming that, According to Los Angeles officials, 16 adult film performers have "recently" tested HIV positive
But unless you're speaking in geological terms, most people don't define "recently" as five years ago, and four of the cases included in that 16 are Darren James and the women he infected, Lara Roxx, Merisa Arroyo and Jessica Dee.
But scare headlines are what sell newspapers and move websites up in the Alexa ratings when what's called for is objective, factual reporting.
So here are a few of the obvious factual errors and misleading statements contained in the recent news stories:
In all, 16 men and 5 women who worked as adult film industry performers contracted HIV between 2004 and 2008 : As the L.A. Times notes, that number, which it says came from the County Department of Health includes both the cluster around
Darren James, one transsexual performer who contracted the infection at roughly that same time ... and 10 ... cases involv[ing] men who had sex with other men.
But that "detail" simply raises more questions. It's well known that some men have sex with other men, including both gay and straight male porn stars, but the difference between them is that gay porn stars generally don't get tested for
HIV on a regular basis, while the males in hetero movies do. And sadly, that lack of testing combined with the subgenre of "bareback" productions is a volatile combination.
So: Subtracting the four Darren James-related cases in 2004, the one transsexual case from that time, the 10 cases of men who had sex with other men, which may be related to the gay bareback industry — that too awaits confirmation — and the
one case discovered last week, that leaves a total of seven cases possibly unaccounted for over that five-year period.
AVN's investigation continues, but it couldn't hurt for the mainstream press, and the adult industry at large, to heed Mitchell's admonition that, Rumor is rampant when the words 'HIV' and 'porn' are in the same sentence; the media is like a
moth to a flame. We are finding that many clients, patients and companies are tempted to discuss this delicate matter with the world for whatever personal or professional gain. Fact is, that we are still awaiting final confirmation on the Patient
After the Los Angeles Times reported that as many as 16 actors and actresses in the adult entertainment
industry recently tested positive for HIV, AIDS Healthcare Foundation (AHF) will host a press conference, protest and rally Monday, June 15th at 9:00pm at porn impresario Larry Flynt's Hustler/Hollywood Store on the Sunset Strip in West Hollywood
(8920 Sunset Blvd.) to call for the introduction of landmark California legislation that would require the use of condoms by actors performing in porn videos produced by California's multi-billion dollar adult entertainment industry—a mainstay of
the San Fernando Valley economy.
AIDS Healthcare Foundation, the US' largest non-profit HIV/AIDS healthcare provider, which operates the largest community-based alternative HIV testing program in California conducting more than 14,000 free HIV tests annually, believes the State
of California should mandate the use condoms by actors performing in films produced by the California industry. AHF further believes a condoms in porn bill should be drafted as a worker safety provision of California's Labor Code akin to
how the Labor Code currently requires the use of hard hats and other garments and barriers as safely precautions on certain California work sites and locations.
Update: Reported cases are not currently active performers
LA County public health officials backtracked on the number of previously unpublicized HIV cases in adult film performers Tuesday, saying they don't know if those who tested positive were actively working in the industry at the time. Officials
also corrected the number of new cases adjusting the figure upward from 16 to 18.
On Tuesday, the department told the Times it does not know if any of the people who tested positive were actively performing in the adult film industry. County public health officials said they mislabeled all reports from the clinic as adult
performers, when they had no information about their occupations.
The Adult Industry Medical Foundation, the San Fernando Valley clinic that serves the porn industry, said none of the people were actively performing when they were tested. Clinic co-founder Sharon Mitchell said each case involved either a
non-performer or an aspiring actor or actress who tested positive, then dropped out of the business.
The female actress who tested positive for HIV at their clinic earlier this month remains the only case detected in a working performer since 2004, Mitchell said.
AVN (Adult Video News), a major trade journal for the US adult entertainment industry, announced plans to consolidate four of their six
print publications into one monthly trade magazine.
We are simply acting responsibly in a tumultuous market. This move reflects a trend of consolidation in the adult entertainment market itself, and allows us at the same time to return to our roots, explains Darren Roberts, AVN's CEO.
Paul Fishbein, AVN's President, said: The rise of digital media, combined with a downturn economy, has definitely taken a bite out of traditional print advertising revenue, which enjoyed years of vigorous growth.
A Texas Court of Appeals panel has upheld a lower court ruling striking down a tax that imposed a $5 tariff for each customer
entering a sexually oriented business (SOB).
On appeal, Texas Comptroller Susan Combs argued that the SOB tax does not violate the 1st Amendment nor the Texas Constitution, that sovereign immunity bars suit by the Texas Entertainment Association and that the trial court erred in awarding
But the appeals court judges had concern over a tax that was a content-based speech regulation and subjected to the strict scrutiny required to determine if the regulation were narrowly tailored to serve a compelling governmental
Evidence that the SOB tax is aimed at reducing secondary effects of sexually oriented businesses does not preclude the proper application of strict scrutiny in this case, the court ruled.
In addition, the court overruled the sovereign immunity and attorneys fees claims by the Texas comptroller.
At post time, it wasn't clear whether the comptroller will appeal the decision to the Texas Supreme Court.
At least one legal brothel in Nevada is trying to add men to its menu of services.
Business is down at the Shady Lady Ranch, where owner Bobbi Davis hopes to start hiring male prostitutes to add to the lineup at the small, roadside brothel to try to lure new female customers: We've had requests for men in the past, and
there's nothing else like this out there.
Nevada Brothel Association lobbyist George Flint says others also have tried over the years, with little success. He argues that the business model for a brothel that caters to women just doesn't pencil out.
Seducing a woman and seducing a man in a brothel environment are different things completely. One can take a few minutes, the other can take hours. It wouldn't make money, he said.
Like Nevada's gambling, hotel and convention industries, the prostitution business has hit hard times. Flint estimates that bordellos have seen a roughly 50% drop in revenue since the economy turned sour.
At least for now, Davis plans to keep her current prices for services—$500 for two hours, $800 for three.
That may change. We're figuring that women may want a longer period of time, maybe a little more romance. They're not quite like men in that respect, she said.
Davis is drawing up her help wanted ad. She said she'll be looking for one or two men in good shape, in their mid-30s to 50s.
After receiving threats of criminal charges from South Carolina Attorney General Henry McMaster over its alleged refusal to block
prostitution and graphic pornographic ads on the site, Craigslist yesterday sued McMaster, seeking declaratory relief and a restraining order against the charges. In addition to being unwarranted by the facts, legal experts agree that the
charges threatened represent an unconstitutional prior restraint on free speech, and are clearly barred by federal law, Craigslist CEO Jim Buckmaster wrote in a blog post.
A number of state attorneys general went after Craigslist, prompting the company to voluntarily agree to remove the section entirely, and henceforth manually screen for prostitution or graphic pornography in ads.
McMaster, however, continued to threaten criminal prosecution against the company and its executives.
Despite Craigslist's legal immunity from criminal or civil liability under state law for unlawful third-party content on its website, and despite the numerous good-faith actions that Craigslist has voluntarily taken to deter abuse of its
service by third parties ... McMaster has persisted in threats to criminally prosecute Craigslist on the basis of third-party content appearing on the Craigslist website, reads the company's legal complaint.
In a statement on Wednesday, McMaster backpedaled somewhat. Talk of a criminal investigation, supposedly already underway, was replaced with McMaster saying his office will continue to monitor the site to make certain that our laws are
A state law restricting billboards that advertise for strip clubs and sex shops does not violate the First Amendment, lawyers
for Kansas Attorney General Stephen Six argued.
The arguments came in court papers in response to a federal lawsuit filed by a company that operates a central Kansas adult store challenging the constitutionality of a law that prevents such businesses from having any outdoor advertising within a
mile of a state highway starting July 1.
The lawsuit was filed by company which operates Lions Den Adult Superstore in Abilene. The store is seeking a temporary order to prevent the state from enforcing the statute. It argues that the law violates First Amendment guarantees of free
speech and Fourteenth Amendment guarantees of due process.
But attorneys for Six wrote that the store's billboards aren't protected by the First Amendment because they don't concern lawful activity. Six's lawyers also argued that the law survives First Amendment scrutiny because it advances
substantial governmental interests.
The statute allows onsite signs for businesses that are within a mile of a state highway. But they can have just two signs: One giving the shop's name, address, phone number, operating hours and a statement, and the other stating that minors are
not allowed. The identification sign can also be no larger than 40 square feet. Violation of the statute is a misdemeanor, punishable by up to a month in the county jail and a fine of up to $500.
The lawsuit notes similar state statutes already have been struck down in Missouri, Georgia and South Carolina.
The Rhode Island House Judiciary Committee have approved a bill to criminalize prostitution that occurs indoors, with a
full vote on the House floor expected soon.
The bill, which the committee approved in an 8-to-4 vote, seeks to rewrite a nearly 30-year-old law that outlaws streetwalkers and soliciting for prostitution outdoors, but has no prohibition against prostitution that occurs indoors.
Rhode Island is the only state, except for certain counties in Nevada, that has no prohibition against indoor prostitution.
Supporters of the bill include state and local police, who claim that it’s needed to investigate and prosecute cases where prostitutes may be coerced or forced into prostitution, generally defined as human trafficking.
Opponents of the bill generally fall into two categories: those such as the American Civil Liberties Union, which opposes what it views as an intrusion into peoples’ privacy, and those such as members of Brown University Students Against Human
Trafficking, who say that criminalizing indoor prostitution will mean prosecuting prostitutes, who they view as victims.
The amended version of the prostitution bill (H-5044 Sub A) includes exemptions for women who were “forced” into prostitution. Under the bill approved last night, anyone found guilty of prostitution or of procuring the services of a prostitute
(both misdemeanors) would face imprisonment of up to six months, and a fine of $250 to $1,000. For a subsequent offense, they could face up to a year in prison and a fine of $500 to $1,000.
The committee’s chairman, Rep. Donald J. Lally Jr said: I’m very confident we’ll pass it on the floor of the House.
Rhode Island House lawmakers have voted 62-8 to criminalize the solicitation of sexual acts behind closed doors. It now heads for a vote in the Senate, where identical legislation is pending.
The push comes in response to years of whinges by police that Rhode Island's law essentially permitted brothels to operate in plain sight.
It's a black eye for Rhode Island, and I believe it's time we close the loophole, said Rep. Joanne Giannini who sponsored the bill ending the distinction between indoor and outdoor prostitution.
If it becomes law, prostitutes could be punished by a prison term of up to six months in prison and a maximum $1,000 fine for a first offense. Subsequent convictions would carry a prison term of up to one year and similar fines.
Those convicted of hiring a prostitute would face the same penalties.
Pressure from US officials has forced classified advertising website Craigslist to pull the shutters down on its controversial sex
adverts in favour of a new, closely-monitored system.
Craigslist chief executive Jim Buckmaster said the site would be closing the erotic services category next week. Instead, the site will open a new adult services category, in which every advert will be manually approved by staff
before it is seen by members of the public.
the new balance struck today will be an acceptable compromise.
The website has consistently rejected claims that it encourages prostitution, saying that it had often assisted law enforcement in their investigations and kept records of everybody who had advertised on the site. Despite such protestations,
however, the attacks sparked a period of concerted pressure.
After similar public statements by politicians around the US, Buckmaster met with attorneys general from several US states in an attempt to broker a truce. That meeting appears to have led to today's solution, which was greeted positively by
Connecticut attorney general Dick Blumenthal, who was at the meeting last week, said that the change was a good move - but that the site had to prove that it would continue its commitment: We're very encouraged that Craigslist is doing the
right thing in eliminating its online red light district with prostitution and pornography in plain sight. We'll be watching and investigating critically to make sure this measure is more than just a name change.
US attorneys general have met with Craigslist to discuss concerns that the free online classified service is being used to
We are optimistic that our shared concerns can be addressed while preserving the beneficial aspects of Craigslist...without compromising the quintessentially American values of free speech embodied in our Constitution, the website's chief
executive Jim Buckmaster told AFP after the meeting.
Missouri misery attorney general Chris Koster said prior to the meeting that he intended to begin negotiating with Craigslist representatives to eliminate Erotic Services ads that amount to little more than offers of sex for sale.
US law protects Craigslist and other websites from being responsible for content posted by users, the website's lawyers argue.
Craigslist is responsible for the types of advertisements it allows, and it is imperative that Craigslist agree to tougher restrictions and to remove ads for illegal activities from its site, Koster claimed.
SP Star, Owners of Little Tokyo Showgirls, have every right to free speech but not to sell alcohol, a California
appeal court has ruled.
Little Tokyo Showgirls in downtown Los Angeles in a heavily industrial area. At one point the club was a Penthouse-branded gentlemen’s club.
But the club has been road-blocked by the city Planning Commission over the issue of not being able to obtain a liquor license, which was the reason SP Star decided to sue the city. Without a liquor license, SP Star said, business partner
Penthouse bailed from the deal.
But the state Court of Appeal affirmed a Los Angeles Superior Court order that denied a conditional use permit allowing liquor sales at the club. In the suit, SP Star said out that if it would sell liquor, it would be required by Alcoholic
Beverage Control regulations to limit its entertainment to topless dancing on a stage at least six feet from the nearest patron.
The city zoning administrator agreed to grant the permit for one year. But later, the Hompa Hongwanji Buddhist Temple and the operators of the Fukui mortuary appealed the zoning administrator’s decision.
Fukui voiced 'fears' that sale of liquor 'so close' to the mortuary would lead to mourners being disturbed. Fukui is three blocks from the club.
City Council members also opposed the permit claiming that that disaster follows if you combined alcohol, testosterone and late hours.
A Planning Commission official also predicted the facility would become a magnet for inmates being released from the Twin Towers county jail a few blocks away, and for denizens of the nearby Skid Row area.
Craigslist isn't closing down the well-visited erotic services section of the ad-posting site, though it will continue to work to remove inappropriate material.
Appearing on ABC's Nightline site founder Craig Newmark said users already flag questionable postings.
As reported by AVN.com, Connecticut Attorney General Richard Blumenthal sent a letter to Craigslist outlining steps to combat the proliferation of prostitution and pornography on the ad site, including the banning of photos in the erotic services section
and the hiring of staff to screen for violating images.
Despite accusations that Craigslist enables and aids in prostitution, including a lawsuit filed in Illinois by the Cook Country Sheriff's office, Internet legal experts believe such actions won't be effective as Section 230 of the Communications Decency
Act states websites are immune from liability when users of the site violate state law.
Craigslist has claimed that erotic services postings have dwindled since new restrictions and criteria were put into place.
Nutters thought they'd struck a goldmine when Dr. Richard McCleary of UC-Irvine's Department of Criminology, Law and Society issued a report titled Secondary Effects of 'Off-site' Sexually-Oriented Businesses, which claimed to study the adverse
effects of 14 Texas adult stores which offered adult videos for rental or sale. McCleary claimed that even though no business took place on the premises of most of the stores except adult video rentals, that they nonetheless posed large, statistically
significant ambient crime victimization risks.
The Berlin (CT) Town Council also thought it had come across a useful tool to control adult oriented stores. The McCleary report is cited in the ordinance, enacted Feb. 5, 2009, as one of the materials and information regarding sexually oriented
business that it used to justify a restrictive new ordinance.
Opponents of the Berlin ordinance turned to UC-Santa Barbara sociology Prof. Dan Linz, himself a veteran of several secondary effects studies, to look over the McCleary report and determine if its findings were consistent with the statistical evidence.
Linz examined the McCleary study in concert with Profs. Jeffrey Cancino and John McCluskey of the Department of Criminal Justice at the University of Texas-San Antonio.
Cancino and McCluskey did their own examination of the same statistics McCleary claimed to have used for his report, and produced their own study titled, Report 2: An Empirical Analysis of Dr. Richard McCleary's San Antonio SOB Case Study (Secondary
Effects of 'Off-Site' Sexually-Oriented Businesses) Commissioned by the Texas City Attorney's Association, and found a myriad problems with the McCleary study.
For instance, Cancino and McCluskey found that of the 14 SOB locations which McCleary used for his study, nine were not located even near where he said they were.
All 14 adult businesses (13 depending if one includes Temptations) have substantial distance errors from where the business is actually located on the centerline street map, the Cancino/McCluskey study found: The distance errors range from 52
to 1,105 feet. The severity of these errors renders his study an invalid scientific analysis of secondary effects.
Worse, Cancino/McCluskey found that one-fifth of the addresses McCleary used to map the police calls actually had non-adult businesses located at those addresses during part of the time frame McCleary used, and that he had misclassified some of the
on-site adult businesses as off-site, and vice-versa.
I conclude McCleary's arguments regarding the criminogenic nature of the 14 adult locations presented in his San Antonio study is not proof of secondary effects due to substantial and fatal methodological errors, the Cancino/McCluskey report
concludes: The analysis is shoddy as locations are misclassified geographically, the locations were not adult video stores during the study period, and the video store classifications appear to be incorrect given re-inspection of the sites in late
2008. Though couched in the language of careful scientific analysis, closer examination reveals that Dr. McCleary's San Antonio study offers no credible scientific evidence of secondary effects. Given the flaws with this study it cannot be reasonably
relied upon in assessing the secondary effects of off site adult businesses.
The measure that would create a 12% excise tax on all tangible adult entertainment products in California has been dropped for the legislative season but still is alive.
Assembly Bill 1082 is slated as a two-year bill and will be brought back in August when the Legislature reconvenes after summer recess, according to Allegra Kim, a legislative analyst for state Assemblyman Alberto Torrico who sponsored the measure.
But for the time being, Free Speech Coalition Executive Director Diane Duke is elated: We’re thrilled. We dodged another one, but there always are those who believe in the absurdity of a bill like this one. I think there always will be those who want
to abridge the industry’s free-speech rights.
FSC was joined by the American Civil Liberties Union, which said that the U.S. Supreme Court has made it clear that a tax on First Amendment protected speech will not withstand constitutional scrutiny and that the tax imposed by this bill is an
unconstitutional, content-based regulation on speech that impermissibly burdens vast amounts of protected expression.
Marilyn Chambers, adult star of such golden age classics as Behind the Green Door and Insatiable , was found dead Sunday in the mobile home where she had been living for the past several months. She was 56, but would have celebrated her
next birthday on April 22. Chambers was found by her daughter, McKenna. No cause of death is yet known, and an autopsy will be performed.
Chambers' first movie was Behind the Green Door , a landmark for its time both because it featured the 99 and 44/100 percent pure girl - Chambers had appeared recently as the cover girl on boxes of Ivory Snow detergent - and because
it featured her in a scorching interracial scene with popular performer Johnnie Keyes.
In 1983, she starred in the sexy spy thriller Angel of H.E.A.T ., and in '77, snagged the starring role in David Cronenberg's horror film Rabid . She also created several sexy titles for cable TV, including Party Girls, New York Nights,
Bedtime Fantasies and Sextrospective.
In all, Chambers appeared in just 23 hardcore films, including Behind the Green Door, The Resurrection of Eve, Inside Marilyn Chambers, Beyond DeSade, Never a Tender Moment, Insatiable 1 & 2, Charli, Up 'n Coming, Marilyn Chambers' Private
Fantasies 1-6, Still Insatiable, Dark Chambers, Edge Play, Marilyn Chambers' Guide to Dirty Dancing, Nantucket Housewives, Marilyn Chambers' Guide to Anal Sex, Marilyn Chambers' Guide to Masturbation and Marilyn Chambers' Guide to Oral Sex.
A proposal to levy a $5 tax on sex acts in Nevada has died in a state Senate committee.
The 3-4 vote Thursday in the Nevada Senate Taxation Committee was one shy of the four needed to keep the proposal afloat.
Committee Chairman Bob Coffin, the Las Vegas Democrat who sponsored the bill, says the state is desperate for revenue and has not collected taxes from prostitution since it was legalized in some rural counties more than 30 years ago.
Texas legislators have given a green light for a new tax on sexually oriented businesses that would replace a measure that taxes patrons entering strip clubs.
Under H.B. 982, a $5-per-person gentlemen's club fee would be repealed and replaced with a 10% tax to those sexually oriented businesses that charge an admission fee.
The bill, introduced by Representative Senfronia Thompson and endorsed by the adult entertainment industry, passed the House on Thursday.
This bill is unlike the $5 admission tax that has been tied up in the courts since the last legislative session, Thompson told XBIZ: The free-speech issue that has dogged that one has been eliminated with this bill. We are charging a tax, in
this case, to do business in the state of Texas.
Thompson noted the proposed tax does not target nude dancing, a form of expression a Texas court ruled is protected by the First Amendment.
She said that the bill was hammered out with the help of members of the Texas Entertainment Association, which is an industry trade association for Texas strip-club owners. She noted that there are 115 known strip clubs in the state.
The bill's target is strip clubs, but it could be expanded to other sectors. H.B. 982 defines sexually oriented businesses to include any commercial enterprise selling, renting or exhibiting items [and services] intended to provide sexual stimulation
or sexual gratification to the customer.
Strip owners who have paid the state under the old fee would get a credit toward the new tax, which would go into effect as early as July 1. Thompson said that the bill has moved on to a fast track in the Legislature and could be signed into law by the
governor within weeks.
Seattle's Attorney, Tom Carr, suggested that on top of fines and jail time, men now face a $150 fee and re-education classes for patronizing a
The Seattle City Council have now approved the fee. The money will go to pay for re-education classes for both prostitutes and their customers.
Prostitution or patronizing a prostitute is a misdemeanor punishable by up to $1,000 and 90 days in jail.
Carr said his office sees about 100 cases a year of people patronizing prostitutes, a level that has remained constant over the past 10 years. He did not have figures immediately available on cases of people committing prostitution.
The new legislation extends legislation passed in 1994, when the council required people convicted of prostitution to take a class on sexually transmitted diseases. The class eventually morphed into a peer-counselling session run by a former prostitute
and showed success at helping women get out of the sex trade, Carr said.
Funding for the classes dried up in recent years, so Carr proposed setting up a new fee to fund the classes. He also proposed a class for prostitutes' customers, modelled on a program in San Francisco.
" ou look at men who are patronizing and you bring in someone who has been a prostitute and humanize the whole person, Carr said.
We are realizing more and more that the person involved in prostitution is in many cases a victim as well, and are often subjected to coercive violence, threats. It can be a pretty ugly existence. Our desire is to offer counselling and solutions that
will move them out of that experience.
Nevada senator Bob Coffin has proposed a $5 tax on every prostitution transaction that occurs in the state, according to a Las Vegas
Sun report. Coffin says the tax would raise an additional $2 million a year for Nevada, and a lobbyist for the legal brothel industry supports the idea.
I think we will support [the tax], said George Flint, director of the Nevada Brothel Owners Association. There are 28 legal brothels operating in Nevada, along with illegal unlicensed prostitution, and prostitution is actually illegal in the city
of Las Vegas. Coffin's proposed tax would apply to both legal and illegal prostitution.
The proposed tax would be paid by customers, not levied from the prostitutes' wages.
Florida legislators are looking at next year's budget and trying to figure out how to balance it — and one of the answers they're
coming up with is to do it partly on the back of the state's adult industry.
According to an article on MSNBC.com, two (unnamed) state legislators have argued that new taxes on sex businesses should be considered, encompassing every facet of adult products from sexually oriented websites to the novelties and lingerie sold
at boutiques, to DVDs and magazines sold at adult book- and video stores. And they haven't forgotten door fees at adult nightclubs, either.
No such content-based taxes have successfully been enacted except for a $5 adult club entry surcharge in Texas, and even those proceeds are being escrowed as Texas club owners continue to fight that pole tax. Similar attempts in Washington state,
New York and California have been defeated.
It's a vast untapped source of revenue in Florida — one that could be as reliable as taxes on drinking and smoking, MSNBC's reporter wrote, recognizing however that: One barrier to such a tax is that opponents would try to overturn it on
grounds it could violate free speech rights.
Texas State is holding $11.2 million in fees collected from strip club patrons pending the action of an appeals court.
A $5 fee for strip club patrons was passed into law in 2007, with the money collected to fund sexual assault services in 54 Texas counties and health insurance programs. Last year, a judge struck down the law, saying that topless dancing was protected as
free speech and that the state couldn't show a link between strip clubs and inadequate health insurance. The state has appealed, and the appeals court has not yet ruled.
Though the Texas Comptroller's Office continues to collect the fee, only some topless clubs are paying it. Some clubs have argued that collecting the money while the bill is under consideration in court is unfair and affects their cash flow as the
economy slows. The $11.2 million collected is lower than the $40 million that legislative analysts projected in the law's first year.
Representative Ellen Cohen, who authored the original 2007 bill, is pushing a new version this year, which drops the charge to $3 and sends all proceeds to sexual assault programs. Lawyers for the clubs say they'll take it to court if it passes.
We will continue to fight until they stop filing unconstitutional legislation, said Stewart Whitehead, an attorney for the Texas Entertainment Association, which represents topless clubs in Texas: These changes don't get them around the fact
that they are taxing constitutionally protected speech.
Nebraska is attempting to pass a law requiring statewide enforcement on adult entertainment business.
The Associated Press reports a former pornography addict, a state senator, and the Roman Catholic Church are backing a bill that would require all sex-related businesses be located a quarter of a mile from childcare businesses, schools, homes,
playgrounds, recreational facilities, or churches.
In addition, the measure drafted by Senator Mark Christensen says dancers must stay at least six feet away from patrons in clubs where triple-x dancing occurs -- and if they want to go out and intermix with the patrons, then they do need to dress.
The bill also prohibits the removal of clothing in those establishments after 11 p.m.
In the longest running obscenity case in American history, Extreme Associate owners Rob Black and Lizzy Borden have each entered guilty
pleas to one count of conspiracy to distribute obscene material. Trial had been scheduled to begin with jury selection on Monday.
The plea capped a legal battle, begun in 2003 with a 10-count indictment, that had promised to deal with cutting edge free speech issues.
In fact, just three videos were indicted - Forced Entry and Cocktails 2 , both directed by Borden, and Extreme Teen 24 , credited to Stanley Ferrara but reportedly the work of several directors - as well as six video clips.
But as noted in AVN's recent editorial , defense of obscenity requires huge amounts of cash, and with Extreme Associates long closed, and Black and Borden reportedly employed only sporadically - and with an almost universal lack of support from the adult
industry - it was too much to expect that attorneys H. Louis Sirkin and Jennifer Kinsley would be willing to handle the projected two-week trial (and its subsequent appeals) on a pro bono basis.
Estimates of the possible sentences that could be imposed under the plea have ranged from as little as 10 months in prison for each individual defendant to as much as five years, and a possible fine of $250,000 for each individual and the corporation.
The couple will be sentenced on July 1.
Craigslist has released statistics it touted as evidence of its 'success' in reducing the volume of erotic services ads appearing
on the Web classified site in an apparent response to a federal lawsuit that accuses the site of facilitating prostitution.
The number of ads for such services is down 90-95% during the past 12 months on Craigslist sites that serve five major U.S. cities, according to information posted on a company blog. The site credited the spectacular reduction on its joint effort
with 40 attorneys general which included the introduction of new measures that require posters to the erotic section to furnish a working phone number and credit card:
General and law enforcement.
Finally, net revenue is accumulating from the fees now required of those posting under "erotic services," 100% of which is earmarked for donation to worthy charities, and we will soon be in position to begin distributing
The blog posting is an apparent response to a federal lawsuit filed against Craigslist by the sheriff of Illinois' Cook County, alleging that the Web's largest classifieds publication is facilitating prostitution. Sheriff Tom Dart asked the court
to force Craigslist to remove the Web publication's erotic section and for $100,000 in compensation for the man-hours the county has had to pay police to investigate alleged criminal services being advertised on the site.
Chicago's sheriff has filed a lawsuit against Craigslist, saying the site may be the No. 1 source of prostitution in the United States
and is straining his department's ability to enforce the law.
The suit claims that changes Craigslist enacted in November to its erotic services section have done little to curb prostitution, sex trafficking and child pimping on the site. It seeks a court order requiring the site to close the section and to pay the
costs the department incurs in cracking down on hookers and Johns who use the it.
The sheriff conducts stings through Craigslist regularly, the complaint, filed Federal Court in Chicago said. However, the deluge of erotic services postings taxes its resources. The sheer number of daily postings has made it impossible to
stymie Craigslist generated prostitution.
Under the new requirements announced in November, erotic services advertisers must first register with the site using a computerized telephone verification routine and pay a $5 fee (most ads are free). The site promises to turn over telephone and credit
card information to law enforcement agencies with a valid court order.
The lawsuit contended. Pimps and prostitutes continue to post more than 300 posts per day to Chicago's erotic services section: While defendant does not profit from erotic services per se, erotic services is the catalyst behind Craigslist being the
ninth most popular website in the country. Erotic services enables defendant to charge fees of up to $75 per post for job openings due to the significant web traffic garnered by erotic services."
State Assemblyman Alberto Torrico has introduced a bill that would place a tax on adult entertainment products sold in California.
The tax percentage was not written into the bill introduced Friday; however, Torrico spokesman Jeff Barbosa told XBIZ that the bill is still in the beginning process” and that legislative analysts will provide a tax amount shortly.
The timing of Torrico's proposal comes on the heels of dwindling state coffers, as well as the assemblyman's push to provide a domestic abuser surveillance fund to track abusers and stalkers.
The bill's language, as it stands, only includes a proposed tax on the sale of harmful matter goods at the retail level.
A Colorado man who posed as a police officer in an effort to confiscate pornography from an adult novelty store has pleaded guilty
to impersonating a police officer.
Andrew Libby was sentenced to two years of probation.
His lawyer, Kristi Sanders, says Libby was suffering from delusions when he entered the store last July, saying he was from the Longmont Police Department and needed to inspect pornographic DVDs to look for underage actors.
Sanders says Libby believed the store was involved in illegal activity that he needed to shut down.
Libby is barred from owning weapons or visiting the store during his probation. He also must get mental health treatment.
The ongoing case between the nutter Staunton prosecutor Raymond Robertson and Rick E. Krial, owner of After Hours Video, which led to
convictions on obscenity counts last August, could be nearing its end.
Krial has confirmed that he has agreed not to appeal his obscenity convictions and in return will not be prosecuted on felony charges. Krial also has agreed not to reopen After Hours, which has been temporarily closed since the trial ended.
If the store stayed open, they were going to come at me with all the charges they could, Krial said.
The trial centered around standard adult videos purchased at After Hours Video by undercover agents in October 2007. Krial and his company were found guilty and store manager Tinsley Embrey was acquitted of two charges by the jury.
Two months after the verdicts were handed down, the defense team — which included 1st amendment lawyers Paul Cambria and Louis Sirkin — filed motions to have the convictions set aside, citing numerous improper statements that were aimed at inflaming the passions and prejudices of jurors.
Krial has now said that the fight is over: Nobody needs this kind of aggravatio n.
Krial said other businesses in the city were selling adult videos at the time he applied for and was granted his business license, and the charges against him were a surprise: I didn't expect it because it was already being sold in Staunton. Krial
also runs 11 adult enterprises in Maryland and Virginia.
Robertson is a long time nutter and opponent of adult material. In August 2007 when Robertson heard of Krial's intentions to open the store vowed he was not going to allow dissemination of pornographic material in Staunton. In November 2007, Krial
and his company were indicted by a special grand jury on 16 felonies and eight misdemeanors.
The court order ending the city's prosecution of Rick Krial and the now-defunct After Hours Video store has been signed.
Krial and his company, LSP of Virginia LLC, were found guilty on two misdemeanor obscenity charges by a seven-person jury following a week-long obscenity trial in August, setting the stage for possible future felony convictions. Krial and the company
were fined $2,500 and ordered to pay $160 in court costs.
According to the court order, Staunton prosecutor Raymond Robertson will not pursue 16 felony charges against Krial and the company, and in return Krial has agreed to drop a motion to set aside the verdicts and will not appeal the convictions.
Krial also agreed not to reopen After Hours Video or any other adult video store in Staunton.
The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit has upheld the 2257 federal record-keeping law in the long-contested
Writing for the majority, Circuit Judge Sutton addressed what he sees as the critical question in this issue: Under what circumstances is it appropriate to invalidate a law in all of its applications when its invalidity can be shown [or assumed] in
just some of its applications?
Sutton went on to discuss the hypothetical middle-aged couple shooting their own erotica — a practice used as an example of the burdensome requirements of the statute. Over twenty years and numerous administrations, the statute has never been enforced
in this setting, and the attorney general has publicly taken the position that he will not enforce the statute in this setting, Sutton wrote.
Opposing the ruling was Circuit Judge Helene N. White, who in writing a dissenting opinion stated her belief that under intermediate scrutiny the identification/record-keeping requirements of 2257 impose an unconstitutional burden on plaintiffs' First
As for the future of the statute it really comes down to whether or not the U.S. Supreme Court will take the case, attorney Larry Walters told XBIZ: But that is much less likely to happen since the circuit court upheld the law, rather than
The upholding of 2257 presents a possible immediate threat to the industry as well:
Webmasters [and others] should be much more concerned about possible inspections and prosecutions, Walters said: Now that the law has been upheld, 2257 inspections could resume at any time.
Addressing fellow members of the Free Speech Coalition, attorney Jeffrey Douglas said the FBI won't show up anytime soon to inspect the records of
adult producers under the revised 2257 regulations.
Douglas' remarks followed in the wake of events which have left the latest changes to 2257 in limbo, leading to questions about the future of the record-keeping laws under President Obama.
The final revisions to 18 U.S.C. §2257 officially took effect Jan. 20, the same day Obama was sworn into office.
Obama's Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel announced on the same day that all regulatory changes not yet in effect from the final days of the Bush regime would be suspended, pending review by the new administration.
After inspecting more than two dozen adult companies in an 18-month period, the Justice Department has yet to bring a single 2257-based criminal case against a mainstream" adult producer.
And the question remains: Will President Obama's administration continue to pursue an even more overcomplicated version of this law?
Playboy Enterprises is open to discussions regarding the sale of the company, interim chairman and CEO Jerome Kern said.
Playboy suffered a net loss of $145.7 million in 2008, partly because of a reported $157.2 million in restructuring costs. The company trimmed 14% of its staff in 2008, and plans more layoffs as it consolidates its online and print divisions in the
In its year-end report for 2008, Playboy reported revenue at $292.1 million, down 14% from $339.8 million in 2007.
Playboy's publishing income fell from $93.8 million to $84.5 million over the course of the year.
The company did see fourth-quarter profits from its TV programming in the U.S., recorded at $5 million. Licensing income, which Playboy has touted as its strongest asset, was down 38%.
Representative Mark Miloscia gave it his best shot, but his proposal to tax adult entertainment products and services to fund
unemployment and welfare benefits is dead - mainly because it's too complicated.
According to the Seattle Post-Intelligencer, Rep. Ross Hunter , chair of the state House Finance Committee, had originally said he'd give a hearing to House Bill 2103, but thought better of it after remembering that the state had previously signed
onto the 2002 Streamline Sales and Use Tax Agreement, whose fundamental purpose is to simplify and modernize sales and use tax administration in the member states in order to substantially reduce the burden of tax compliance.
Miloscia's porn tax bill, it seems, in attempting to put a tax on goods based on their content, wouldn't fly under the simplification agreement - and besides, a tax based on content is just unconstitutional.
In light of a $15 billion state budget deficit, New York Governor, David Paterson, has proposed an additional 4% tax on all digitally delivered entertainment services,
including online adult content.
Following the proposition, the iPod tax was immediately met with criticism from not only the adult entertainment industry, which has largely dismissed the tax as a publicity stunt, but also from the conservatives, who fear that such a tax would
legitimize the downloading and viewing of adult content.
You're sending a message to children, and you're sending a message to teenagers: If you're taxing it, how can it be wrong? said state Conservative Party Chairman Michael Long.
Paterson's proposed tax is the most recent of a seemingly popular trend in that it follows similar propositions in California and more recently, Washington.
At least one constitutional scholar questions the legality of such a tax.
If the tax were limited to [MP3, porn and other entertainment downloads], there would be some substantial problems, said attorney Reed Lee, an expert in constitutional law: If it's an attempt to tax all Internet traffic, whether that be
downloading the latest NASA pictures from Mars for scientific purposes or what, as well as entertainment downloads, then that has a much better chance of passing constitutional muster. In general, a tax designed to impose a burden on specific expression
will face the most serious constitutional obstacles in court.
Lee cited two late-'80s cases involving the Minneapolis Star Tribune newspaper and the Arkansas Writers Project. In the Minneapolis case, the government tried to place a sales tax on newsprint - and failed.
A government can impose a sales tax on newspapers and magazines, so long as it also imposes a sales tax on everything else, Lee explained. But a sales tax on only newspapers and magazines might pose a serious constitutional problem. And one
imposed only on Playboy and Penthouse would face virtually insurmountable problems.
Wisconsin has followed in the footsteps of New York State by passing a stimulus bill that includes a measure for adding sales tax to digital downloads starting October 1. The bill also includes budget cuts as well as a variety of tax increases to patch
Wisconsin's $600m shortfall under its current budget set to expire June 30.
But the bill is getting a lot of media play for its digital tax provisions, fingered as (the arguably misleading moniker of) an "iPod tax." The name obviously downplays the true reach of the tax, which levies a 4 per cent charge on
"digitally delivered entertainment services" including music, movies, e-books, greeting cards, ringtones, and many other downloadable items. It's expected to generate $11m for the state over two years.
Wisconsin state legislature has now approved a 5% tax on Internet downloads to take effect in October.
Backed by Governor Jim Doyle, the tax will apply to music, movies, downloads, games, ringtones, e-books, greeting cards and other items, according to the Associated Press. This would presumably include adult content.
Nevada state Senator Bob Coffin says his state should make brothels legal statewide and tax them to help wipe out a $2 billion budget
Nevada is the only U.S. state with legalized prostitution, but brothels are only allowed in rural counties and pay county taxes only. Coffin proposes that prostitution be decriminalized and that the state get a cut of their revenues, ABC reported Friday.
Coffin said by allowing brothels to open up in Las Vegas, Reno and other cities, the state could reap up to $200 million a year in taxes to apply toward the budget shortfall.
Nevada State lawmakers have decided not to take up the question of whether to expand and tax legalized prostitution in Nevada's biggest cities.
The question was broached, in these hard economic times, whether the city of Las Vegas should have legal houses of prostitution, said Assemblyman Bernie Anderson, D-Sparks, chairman of the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
Nevada Brothel Owners Association chief George Flint said Assembly Speaker Barbara Buckley, D-Las Vegas, informed him that the issue won't be considered.
Support from the leader of the majority party in the Legislature is crucial to move the issue forward. But Buckley said she does not support legalizing prostitution.
I'm disappointed, said Flint, who called the brothel industry the only major industry in the state that doesn't pay taxes: I felt they at least would look at the merits of the issue. I've seen legal and regulated, and illegal and unregulated.
The first is better.
State law currently allows legalized prostitution only in rural counties. It is banned in counties with 400,000+ residents, which means Clark and Washoe counties.
State Senator Bill Morrisette is asking lawmakers to consider allowing cities decide where sexually oriented businesses can open up shop.
Morrisette, a nutter Democrat from Springfield, said his hometown's fight to keep strip club Shakers Bar and Grill out of its centre inspired him to create the resolution.
Oregon's Constitution protects sex shops as a form of free speech, meaning they may open in any commercial zone. But Morrisette said he wants lawmakers to put before voters a constitutional amendment to give nutters more control.
Under his plan, local jurisdictions would not be able to completely ban strip clubs, but rather could create exclusionary commercial zones where they would not be allowed, he said.
A San Francisco supervisor is pushing for a crackdown on permitted businesses that operate as brothels.
Supervisor Carmen Chu has asked the city attorney's office to review massage parlor licensing laws in hopes of making it easier to close operations known for prostitution. A Chronicle investigation earlier this month revealed that Health Department
inspectors suspect at least 50 of the city's 150 licensed massage parlors are places where sex is traded for money.
At some, rooms have tubs and wall-to-wall mirrors, and the workers dress in lingerie. During one bust two years ago, Mayor Gavin Newsom walked in on a man and a woman engaged in a sex act in the business lobby. Despite Newsom's call for action back then,
even that business still operates with a city permit.
That's not uncommon. Over the past few years, federal authorities and local police have made arrests and given citations at places suspected of selling sex, but the businesses are almost never shut down by local health officials.
Health Department officials have said licenses often are not revoked due to a combination of factors. Agency Director Mitch Katz has said the police are responsible for stopping prostitution. Yet the crime is generally considered a low priority and
carries minimal penalties.
Officials also say they lack the resources to aggressively monitor the massage business and to fight the legal battles needed to close brothels. It can be prohibitively expensive to go to court to defend a decision to revoke a license, officials say.
Another hurdle is the vast discretion given to Health Department hearing officers who decide whether a license should be withdrawn. Under current laws, the hearing officer may revoke an owner's permit for a single health code violation - such as
employing a masseuse who wears lingerie. But the hearing officer, who also is a Health Department employee, has broad discretion under flexible guidelines, and revocations have been rare.
The sale of sex toys, and perhaps even the sale of some condoms and lubricants, is now prohibited in Coweta County, Georgia.
The Coweta County Board of Commissioners unanimously voted to approve a new obscenity ordinance and a new ordinance regulating sexually-oriented businesses.
The obscenity ordinance prohibits sale or distribution of obscenity, and prohibits anyone from "knowingly" selling, or possessing with the intent to sell, any device designed or marketed as useful primarily for the stimulation of human
The county's old ordinance specifically exempted condoms from being considered as a stimulation device. The new ordinance makes no such distinction, and would appear to apply to items such as ribbed condoms and various lubricants marketed as having a warming
or tingling sensation.
The ordinance would also seem to apply to in-home toy parties, which are growing in popularity. A violation is punishable by up to six months in jail and/or a fine of up to $1,000.
That ordinance is similar to the old ordinance in that it sets the threshold to be considered a sexually-oriented business at 25% of stock. However, the new ordinance only applies to pornography, that is, books, magazines, videos, pictures, and the like,
depicting sexual acts. The new ordinance widens the 25% threshold to apply to total wholesale and retail value, and limits the sale of such items to no more than 500 square feet in a building. Aisles and walkways used to access such items must be
included in both the 25% and 500 square feet calculations. A business can have no more than 2,000 such items.
Sexually-oriented businesses are allowed in Coweta, but must be in an industrially-zoned area and at least 1,000 feet from schools, parks, churches, day-care centers, and residentially-zoned property.
A federal court case in Pennsylvania will determine whether a California company violated obscenity laws when it distributed pornography
in the Keystone State.
The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reported Sunday that in the case of United States vs. Extreme Associates begins March 16.
The owners of Extreme Associates, which makes pornography featuring scenes of rape, torture, murder and defecation, are accused of sending their products to Pennsylvania, violating local standards of decency.
The newspaper reported that jurors in the case will have to decide whether the materials are patently offensive and whether the materials they have any serious artistic, literary, social or political value.
The questions have to be viewed through the lens of contemporary community standards, the newspaper said, noting that when the U.S. Supreme Court established current obscenity law in its 1973 decision in Miller vs. California, it did not go about
defining those standards.
H. Louis Sirkin, an obscenity lawyer who represents the defendants, says the standards of cyberspace rather than community standards of western Pennsylvania should be used to gauge his clients' conduct.
A proposal to open a topless coffee shop in a commercial building that has been vacant for four years has received unanimous approval.
The Vassalboro, Maine, Planning Board determined the proposal complied with all of the relevant city codes regarding traffic, parking and lighting, and therefore the five board members had no choice but to vote for the project.
Vassalboro has no adult business ordinance, and the Planning Board is not authorized to regulate employees’ attire.
The log-cabin-looking structure on busy Route 3 in the rural community has served as home to bars and restaurants, but none of the businesses have been able to remain open for long, even though one bar occasionally featured exotic dancers. A new venture
at the spot could provide the town with much-needed jobs and tax revenue, some local residents feel. Others are predictably outraged .
Pirates II: Stagnetti’s Revenge sailed off with the lion's share of the booty at the 2009 AVN Adult Movie Awards.
Digital Playground's heavily hyped super-big budget epic scored 15 prizes, including Best Video Feature. That's half the 30 it was nominated for, and four more than the original Pirates in 2006.
Digital Playground took home seven more awards, including four for Cheerleaders and the Best New Starlet prize for contract star Stoya.
Jenna Haze won the highly coveted prize of Female Performer of the Year, making her only the second woman to win both that and Best New Starlet.
The jubilant Jenna drew cheers from the crowd by echoing Jenna Jameson’s infamous remark from last year: I will spread by legs forever in this fucking business for you—this is just the beginning of my sluttiness.
The evening’s oddest moment came when James Deen was announced as Male Performer of the Year. Though he had been quite visible all evening, the notoriously stage-shy actor was suddenly nowhere to be found. He did eventually show up to accept his
award offstage, and later admitted to suffering a panic attack that prevented him from taking the stage. I can have sex in front of a room full of people, but I can't get up on stage and say thank you, Deen told AVN.
In the final year of the anachronistic film categories, the six nominations were split evenly between directors Paul Thomas and Andrew Blake. Vivid won the Best Film trophy for Thomas' Cry Wolf , and Blake's Studio A was awarded Best
Cinematography for Paid Companions.
The award for Best Actress went to jessica drake for Fallen , which she called the best movie I have ever been in.
The awards show began rambunctiously with a number by hip-hop star Flo Rida. It featured an appearance by Larry Flynt and an unusual politically-themed presentation: a video montage of Bush Administration abuses accompanied by an a cappella rendition of
the National Anthem by an uncredited young African-American woman. It brought the audience to its feet.
Dancers will have to give their real names and addresses to the state of North Dakota under a bill that would require registration for
Police from Fargo and West Fargo say the so-called sexually oriented business bill should help crack down on prostitution and drug trafficking they associate with nude dancers. No license is currently required.
It's common practice for the individuals who are participating as the service provider to use fictitious names, or stage names, said Mike Reitan, assistant police chief kill joy in West Fargo: We don't have any way of identifying who these
The bill defines a sexually oriented business as an individual or commercial enterprise that advertises, offers or provides live nude entertainment for a fee, or in connection with any other transfer of money. The law would require someone who
runs a such a business to register with the state tax commissioner.
Failing to register would be a Class B misdemeanor, which carries a maximum penalty of 30 days in jail and a $1,000 fine.
Senator Judy Lee, R-Fargo, a sponsor of the bill, said she introduced the bill at the request of police officials. The bill is SB2170.
Porn kings Larry Flynt and Joe Francis are calling on the US government to revive the sex lives of Americans by
providing a $5 billion bailout of the country's adult entertainment industry.
Hustler magazine publisher Flynt and Girls Gone Wild founder Francis have sent a joint request to the Government asking for the bailout to help them ride out the economic crisis.
The pair said while the porn industry was still viable, the economic crunch had taken its toll.
Francis said as the government was prepared to bail out other faltering industries such as car-manufacturers, they should be willing to help the porn industry.
Congress seems willing to help shore up our nation's most important businesses; we feel we deserve the same consideration, the statement is reported to have said.
Flynt said the downturn was having an unhealthy affect on the sexual appetites of Americans: People are too depressed to be sexually active . This is very unhealthy as a nation. Americans can do without cars and such but they cannot do without
A Georgia state senator said that he is thinking of imposing fees on strip club patrons supposedly to help fund programs for victims of sexual
abuse. Surely the reality is more moral than charitable.
The legislation, proposed by Senator Jack Murphy, would charge between $3 and $5 per visitor at every strip club in Georgia. Murphy says he would forward the additional revenue to therapeutic programs for victims of child prostitution and other forms of
sex-related abuse because the state has cut funding for a lot of such services to compensate for statewide falling revenues.
Although Lt. Gov. Casey Cagle, who presides over the state senate, says he is reluctant to add such a fee because this is not the time for raising taxes.
Many in opposition to the proposed legislation argue that a fee would not only make a difference, but also put many of these strip clubs out of business.
You’re not just putting a tax on the patrons of the adult clubs, said Aubrey Villines, a lawyer who has represented strip-club-owner Jack Galardi. What does it do to the waitresses, to the food workers, to the parking attendants? The
people who all depend on this industry for work?
A similar strip-club fee of $5 per patron was instated in Texas in January 2008. In this case, a state district judge ruled in March that the fee was unconstitutional in that it violated the First Amendment.
Murphy says he will announce his final decision after consulting legislative leadership.
Two years after San Francisco Mayor Gavin Newsom called for a crackdown on brothels that front as massage parlors, city health officials say they know of more than 50 city-licensed establishments where they suspect sex is traded for money.
Yet health officials have no plans to revoke the city permits and shut them down, despite several cases where undercover officers have cited workers for soliciting sex. One parlor continues to operate even though, during a raid, the mayor personally
walked in on a man engaged in a sex act with a young woman on the lobby couch.
The sex shops exist in plain sight from the Sunset District to downtown, serving clients who walk into so-called spas, often with bathtubs, wall-to-wall mirrors and scantily clad women. In some places, the women are willing participants.
Some health department staff members say they're frustrated. There is only one inspector to oversee the city's 150 sites with massage permits, and officials say they lack the legal and financial resources to aggressively pursue cases where they suspect
And despite the mayor's professed interest in going after the erotic massage parlors, the official line at the health department is that that the agency's job is to look for health code violations - not stop prostitution.