The Scottish Parliament has rejected proposed legislation that would have criminalised the act of paying for sex. The Prostitution (Offences and Support) (Scotland) Bill tabled by independent MSP Ash Regan, would have created a criminal offence for
paying for sexual services and repealed the existing offence of soliciting. It was rejected by 64 votes to 54, with no abstentions. The bill fell at stage one, when MSPs are asked to agree its general principles. The government did not
support the bill. Ministers said they supported the fundamental principle of the proposals but argued the bill was too flawed to be passed before Holyrood splits up for May's election. Victims minister Siobhian Brown expressed regret that the
government could not support the bill, but said there was not sufficient time to develop the proposals and address very significant issues they have with the bill. The minister had raised doubts about how the new offence could be enforced, noting
particular concerns over online activity. She also cited concerns that the bill could increase the risk of violence against sex workers because it could reduce their ability to assess the risk of buyers. | 
