The
Advertising Standards Authority has recommended that a Christian group
be censured for predicting that Government initiatives on teenage
sexuality, including the HPV vaccine, will increase infertility among
the young.
Christian Voice's Advertorial in the New Statesman earlier
this year, which was headlined VIOLENT CRIME - SOWING AND REAPING,
will be found to breach ASA codes on principles, substantiation and
truthfulness.
The text of the advertorial said: There is a Biblical principle that
we reap what we sow. It applies to nations as well as to individuals.
What politicians sow, the people reap. When politicians sow evil, the
people reap misery, and the poorest reap it the worst. The ad went
on to describe the detrimental impact of government policies and
legislation on society. It included the text Now we have the disaster
of teenage infertility. Every government initiative, including the HPV
vaccine, will increase it, but as all the targets revolve around
pregnancy, no-one in power knows how many young people they are making
sterile and nobody cares.
The officials demanded robust, scientific evidence that the HPV
vaccine caused infertility in teenagers, missing the nutter view
that it is the encouragement of promiscuity in Government teen sex
initiatives which spreads the infections which do the damage, not the
vaccine itself.
Their draft ruling says: the claim "Every government initiative,
including the HPV vaccine, will increase it [teenage infertility]" was a
statement of fact that was capable of substantiation. Christian
Voice say requiring the substantiation of a future prediction in an
opinion piece is preposterous and an infringement of freedom of speech.
Stephen Green, National Director of Christian Voice, said today: It
is a good job the Advertising Standards Authority was not around when
the Old Testament was written, or we would be missing half the Christmas
story. The ASA would have wanted Isaiah to substantiate his claim that
'a virgin shall conceive and shall bear a son' (Isa 7:14). They would
have demanded 'robust, scientific evidence' that virgins can conceive.
It is simple common sense to realise that with the HPV vaccine, girls
will think they are covered against everything, especially if they are
on the pill as well, so promiscuity will rise and there will be even
more Gonorrhoea and Chlamydia cases and even more infertility.
It is preposterous for the ASA to think they can outlaw Christian
freedom of speech and free expression of opinion. The ASA may not like
the fact that sodomy is an abomination in holy scripture, but they
cannot alter it. Nor can their officials change God's word that sex
outside marriage brings judgment. The Free Presbyterian Church will not
back down, and by God's grace neither shall we. We shall keep telling
Government and the teen sex industry that they are betraying young
people in this country and that only God's ways of chastity and fidelity
will halt the rise in teenage pregnancies and infertility.
Update:
ASA Censure Confirmed
29th January 2009. See
article
from
asa.org.uk
An advertising feature in the New Statesman, on behalf of a religious
group, had the headline VIOLENT CRIME - SOWING AND REAPING. Text
underneath stated There is a Biblical principle that we reap what we
sow. It applies to nations as well as to individuals. What politicians
sow, the people reap. When politicians sow evil, the people reap misery,
and the poorest reap it the worst.
The ad went on to describe what the advertisers considered to be the
detrimental impact of government policies and various pieces of
legislation on society. It included the text Now we have the disaster
of teenage infertility. Every government initiative, including the HPV
vaccine, will increase it, but as all the targets revolve around
pregnancy, no-one in power knows how many young people they are making
sterile and nobody cares. Text at the bottom of the ad stated:
Christian Voice. Working for Godly government; praying for national
repentance.
One complainant challenged whether the implied claim that the HPV
vaccine would result in teenage infertility was misleading and could be
substantiated.
ASA Decision
We considered that the claim Every government initiative, including
the HPV vaccine, will increase it [teenage infertility] was a
statement of fact that was a matter open to substantiation. We noted the
webpage submitted by Christian Voice, but we did not consider that that
webpage in itself was sufficient to support the claim. Because we had
not seen robust, scientific evidence that the HPV vaccine caused
infertility in teenagers, we concluded that the claim had not been
substantiated and was misleading.
The ad breached CAP Code clauses 2.2 (Principles), 3.1 (Substantiation)
and 7.1 (Truthfulness).
The ad must not appear again in its current form. We told Christian
Voice not to repeat the implied claim that the HPV vaccine would result
in teenage infertility.