The UK Government has just opened a public consultation on proposals to significantly extend censorship laws for internet TV to match the nannying, burdensome control freakery that currently applies to broadcast TV in the UK. The tone of the press
release highlights the obvious glee that the Government holds for more censorship:
Government to consult on better protections for UK audiences on video-on-demand services
could be better protected from harmful material like misinformation and pseudoscience while watching programmes on video-on-demand services (VoD), Culture Secretary Oliver Dowden has announced.
- Netflix, Amazon Prime Video and Apple TV+ could be subject to stricter rules protecting UK audiences from harmful material
- It would mean audiences - particularly children - receive a
consistent level of protection on video-on-demand services as they do on traditional broadcasters
- Ministers seek views to level the regulatory playing field in consultation launched today
The government is considering how to better level the regulatory playing field between mainstream VoD services and traditional broadcasters and is seeking views on the matter in a consultation launched today. This could mean
aligning the content standards rules for on-demand TV services with those for traditional linear TV like BBC 1 and Sky.
Now that the UK has left the EU there is an opportunity to create regulation suited to UK viewers
that goes beyond the minimum standards as set out in EU regulation under the revised Audiovisual Media Services Directive.
Culture Secretary Oliver Dowden said:
to give UK audiences peace of mind that however they watch TV in the digital age, the shows they enjoy are held to the same high standards that British broadcasting is world-renowned for.
It is right that now we have
left the EU, we look at introducing proportionate new rules so that UK audiences are protected from harm.
Ofcom data shows a huge growth in popularity and use of on-demand services in the UK. The number of
households that subscribe to one rose by almost 350% between 2014 and 2020. In 2021, 75% per cent of UK households say that they have used a subscription VoD service.
Viewers have access to thousands of hours of VoD
shows and content at the touch of a button. However, services like Netflix, Amazon Prime Video and Disney+ are not regulated in the UK to the same extent as UK linear TV channels.
For example, except for BBC iPlayer,
they are not subject to Ofcom's Broadcasting Code which sets out appropriate standards for content including harmful or offensive material, accuracy, fairness and privacy.
This means there is a gap between existing
protections for audiences watching traditional TV and those watching newer VoD services. There are some protections for under-18s but minimal rules exist to regulate content. There are very few rules to protect audiences, for example, from misleading
health advice or pseudoscience documentaries.
Some service providers have taken welcome steps to introduce their own standards and procedures for audience protection - such as pin-codes and content warnings - but the
extent of these measures varies across services. Age ratings are also inconsistent and sometimes non-existent.
The consultation asks for views on whether UK audiences viewing TV-like VoD programmes should receive the
same or similar level of protections as when they are watching traditional television. It asks which measures can and should be made consistent across VoD services.
It will also consider whether mainstream VoD services
not currently regulated in the UK by Ofcom - like Netflix and Apple TV+ - should be brought within UK jurisdiction to provide accountability to UK audiences who use them.
Not all VoD providers deliver a TV-like
experience, so any regulatory change will need to be proportionate, particularly for smaller or niche services, to ensure essential protections like freedom of speech are not affected.
Notes to Editors
consultation is open for 8 weeks and closes on 26 October at 23:45 BST.
- This review into VoD regulation will form part of a number of measures as part of a
wide-ranging broadcasting White Paper into the future of broadcasting which will be published this autumn.
- The consultation examines the current level of audience protection from harmful content provided through
regulation and voluntarily by individual VoD services, and what steps are required to ensure appropriate protection levels for UK audiences going forward.
- Now the UK has left the European Union, this is an
opportunity to improve upon EU aligned provisions under the Audiovisual Media Services Directive with regulations that are designed in the best interests of UK audiences.
- This consultation does not seek responses on
wider broadcasting regulation, nor changes to how television or public service broadcasters such as the BBC or Channel 4 are funded or regulated. This consultation will also not cover changes to advertising rules/restrictions and does not cover topics
such as introducing levies/quotas on VoD services. Responses on these issues will not be considered as part of this consultation.