A
poster, for an animal rights campaign group, featured a picture of Steven
Barker. Text next to the picture stated Steven Barker: Animal Abuser,
Baby Abuser, Rapist. PEOPLE WHO ARE VIOLENT TOWARDS ANIMALS RARELY STOP
THERE. Further text underneath stated Report cruelty to animals
immediately PeTA. Issue
A complainant challenged whether:
- the ad was offensive and distressing, used unnecessary shock
tactics and exploited the death of Baby P
- the ad, which was also located in the area where Baby P lived and
died, was particularly offensive and distressing to residents of that
area.
ASA Assessment: Upheld
The ASA noted PETA's argument that the purpose of the ad was to
inform the public to report animal cruelty in order to prevent future
acts of violence towards humans. We considered, however, that
advertisers who wished to refer to current or emotive news stories in
their marketing should take particular care over how such stories were
used, in order to avoid accusations of exploitation or shock tactics. We
also considered that they should not cause fear or distress without good
reason.
We noted that, although Baby P died in August 2007, his death was a
high-profile, emotive case which continued to get extensive press
coverage. We acknowledged that some people might therefore find the
reference to the Baby P case in the poster exploitative. We considered
that the claim and image used in the ad had been used in a shocking way
merely to attract attention and that the reason did not justify the
means in this case. We therefore also considered that the ad was likely
to cause serious offence and distress to some people.
Furthermore, we noted that the poster had appeared in the area where
Baby P had lived and died. We considered that the ad was likely to be
particularly sensitive for residents of that area, and was likely to
cause serious offence and distress to some residents.
We therefore concluded that the ad was in breach of the Code.
|