Investigators looking into a school district in Pennsylvania that lent out
laptops have discovered thousands of secret photographs were taken of students
in their homes.
The pictures were made possible by tracking software that was
installed on laptops by the Lower Merion School District (LMSD) to allow
them to locate the computers in the event of them being lost or stolen.
A lawsuit filed by the parents of one of the pupils, 15-year-old
Blake Robbins of Harriton High School in Rosemont, claims that the
tracking system captured more than 400 images via his school-issued
laptop over the course of two weeks last autumn and that thousands of
webcam pictures and screen shots have been taken of numerous other
students in their homes.
A minute camera mounted on the computer took snaps of the unwitting
teenager and his relatives including pictures of Blake partially
undressed and of Blake sleeping, as part of a system designed to
take a new picture every 15 minutes while it was switched on, they
claim.
He and his family only became aware that they were being secretly
spied on when Blake was called in by the assistant principal at his
school to be quizzed about one of the images. It showed the boy sifting
through a handful of sweets, which school officials had wrongly presumed
to be illegal drugs.
The school district has claimed that it activated the secret camera
in Blake's computer because his parents had not paid the necessary
insurance fee that allowed him to take it home.
Federal investigators are examining whether the spy programme was
illegal.
Update:
Confirmation
8th May 2010. Based on
article
from bigbrotherwatch.org.uk
An independent report has been released about it today. In essence,
it confirms that the story was true and blames the IT personnel.
According to the report... conducted by a local law firm, the IT
staff not only failed to inform school officials and administrators of
the tracking capabilities of the LANrev software, but argued that
telling students about the software's ability to remotely trigger
notebook Webcams would defeat its purpose as a way to recover
lost or stolen computers.
Update:
Secret Webcams Banned
20th May 2010. Based on article
from bigbrotherwatch.org.uk
A judge has permanently banned a suburban Philadelphia school
district from secretly monitoring students with webcams on their
school-issued laptops.
The Lower Merion School District acknowledges capturing 56,000 screen
shots and webcam images supposedly so it could locate missing laptops.
The new ruling says Lower Merion can use other kinds of technology to
find laptops but only if parents and students agree to it.
The order also requires school officials to arrange for the nearly 40
high school students who were unknowingly photographed by their laptops
to see the images.
Update:
Criminal Prosecution Avoided
22nd August 2010. See article
from theregister.co.uk
Philadelphia school administrators involved in a webcam spying
episode will escape criminal prosecution, federal authorities have
decided after concluding there was no criminal intent in the alleged
surveillance.
I have concluded that bringing criminal charges is not warranted
in this matter, Zane David Memeger, US attorney for the Easter
District of Pennsylvania said in a statement, Wired reports.
For the government to prosecute a criminal case, it must prove
beyond a reasonable doubt that the person charged acted with criminal
intent. We have not found evidence that would establish beyond a
reasonable doubt that anyone involved had criminal intent.
The civil lawsuit - which has a much lower burden of proof - is
unaffected by the decision not to bring charges against the school
administrators involved in the episode. Mark Haltzman, a lawyer suing
the district, told Wired that the prosecutor's ruling in the case
highlighted the need for tougher privacy-protecting legislation.